Which Inkjet printer to buy?

P

puss

Epson has additional gloss optimizer,



NOT IT DOES NOT, only in the R800 and may be up.
while Canon doesn't ...i wonder
why...but i've heard that Epson prints doesn't come as glossy as Canons' .
and that's why gloss optimizer...



Get some facts right next time you post..
 
P

puss

Aha...now from this comes a second question...why does Epson uses pigmented
ink while others use dye ink? It can't be the price...


80 year Life, Dumbo..

Dye inks just don't last..
 
P

puss

Not that i'm Canon's fan, but according to latest tests, Canon's iP4000 has
way cheapest print cost per page. And Canon's head theoretically can't burn
out, since printer will stop printing when it's out of ink, while there are
several complaints about Epson head clogging.



No, its the Ink that corrodes the printhead, Head Rot..

The iP4000 is only a 3 colour Printer.
 
B

Brendan R. Wehrung

Hecate said:
You really., really don't want a Lexmark. They'll come with a one
year warranty and break down completely on day 366 (or day 367 if it's
a leap year). They are the most unreliable inkjets on the market. And
that's not even considering the ridiculous prices they charge for
their cartridges.

--

Hecate - The Real One
(e-mail address removed)
veni, vidi, reliqui


Hasn't happened to me, at least to my Z52, which is 4 years old. Don't
know about the 5700 that preceded it, but I think the problem was a bad
cable. (Didn't worry about it since I'd bought the Z52.) I avoided Epson
becauase of all the clogged head posts, favoring long-term use, which so
far has proved true. Cartridges are expensive but go on sale at Target.

Brendan
--
 
R

Ron Cohen

The iP4000 is a four color, not a three color, CMYK printer. It also has an
additional pigmented black tank for text printing.
--
Ron Cohen

The Nearest New Canon is the PIXMA iP4000, but its still only a 3 colour
printer, 3 colours and 2 blacks..

It does have one nice feature, that is the Dupex unite..

But I can't stand Bubble Jets..


-------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------
Life is not measured by the number of breaths we take, but by the moments
that take our breath away. (George Carlin)
 
P

puss

he iP4000 is a four color, not a three color, CMYK printer. It also has an
additional pigmented black tank for text printing.




Its a 3 Colour, Black is NOT a COLOUR..

The Epson R200/210 is a 5 Colour, Plus Black..
 
A

Arthur Entlich

The gloss optimizer is found in the newest Epson printer(s) which use
pigmented inks. I do not believe Canon has yet sold pigmented ink for
their printers. Pigmented inks, by their very nature, have solid
material in them which doesn't absorb as well into the surface of
papers. Dye inks are mainly carrier and molecular color, so the color
components are very small and very thin and smooth. They either sit
very evenly on top of the paper, or get absorbed and integrated into the
paper,. leaving the surface of a very glossy paper surface very glossy.

Pigmented inks tend to have a rougher and thicker layer, and so a "gloss
optimizer" coats the surface to make it shinier. Also, the papers that
readily handle pigmented ink tend to be less glossy.

Art
 
S

SleeperMan

Arthur said:
The gloss optimizer is found in the newest Epson printer(s) which use
pigmented inks. I do not believe Canon has yet sold pigmented ink for
their printers. Pigmented inks, by their very nature, have solid
material in them which doesn't absorb as well into the surface of
papers. Dye inks are mainly carrier and molecular color, so the color
components are very small and very thin and smooth. They either sit
very evenly on top of the paper, or get absorbed and integrated into
the paper,. leaving the surface of a very glossy paper surface very
glossy.
Pigmented inks tend to have a rougher and thicker layer, and so a
"gloss optimizer" coats the surface to make it shinier. Also, the
papers that readily handle pigmented ink tend to be less glossy.

Canon's black is pigmented...

BTW...i just bought (on resale) some HP semiglossy photo paper, but it's
quite useless in my Canon...either i550 or ip4000.
it's like colors don't absorb, or like printer spits too much of it...
It's fine with other brands of paper, though...
Maybe paper is meant for other type of ink...?
 
A

Arthur Entlich

Pigmented inks have much higher permanence in light fading situations
than do dye inks, regardless of paper type. Some dye inks with the
right combination of paper can have reasonable light fade resistance.

Pigmented inks tend to be waterproof and smudge-resistant with most
papers, again with the right paper so can dye.

Art
 
S

SleeperMan

Arthur said:
Pigmented inks have much higher permanence in light fading situations
than do dye inks, regardless of paper type. Some dye inks with the
right combination of paper can have reasonable light fade resistance.

Pigmented inks tend to be waterproof and smudge-resistant with most
papers, again with the right paper so can dye.

Art

Aha.. thanks
 
A

Arthur Entlich

It would appear you both are saying the exact same thing...

You were a bit more specific as to what each black does.

Art

Ron said:
The iP4000 is a four color, not a three color, CMYK printer. It also has an
additional pigmented black tank for text printing.

The Nearest New Canon is the PIXMA iP4000, but its still only a 3 colour
 
S

SleeperMan

Arthur said:
It would appear you both are saying the exact same thing...

You were a bit more specific as to what each black does.

Art


Pigmented black (BCI-3e) is used for text printing, while dye black (BCI-6)
is used for photo printing. Since colors are dye, dye black mix better with
them than pigment one ---> more quality at photos.
 
A

Arthur Entlich

In most cases, black pigmented inks do not play well with colored inks
that are dye. They require different papers and they don't mix well.

As a result today most printer manufacturers which offer pigmented black
ink (which is great for text, because it is usually deep black and tends
to have lower dot gain or bleeding) often also offer a second black
which is dye for missing with the colors for a photographic image.

When I make the distinction between the Epson pigmented ink series
printers and the Canon dye printers, I am speaking about the overall ink
system, not just the black ink.

HP glossy photo quality papers are mainly swellable polymer type, and
some inks do not do well with that paper technology. I believe Canon
tends to do best with Micropore papers.

Art
 
S

SleeperMan

Arthur said:
In most cases, black pigmented inks do not play well with colored inks
that are dye. They require different papers and they don't mix well.

As a result today most printer manufacturers which offer pigmented
black ink (which is great for text, because it is usually deep black
and tends to have lower dot gain or bleeding) often also offer a
second black which is dye for missing with the colors for a
photographic image.
When I make the distinction between the Epson pigmented ink series
printers and the Canon dye printers, I am speaking about the overall
ink system, not just the black ink.

HP glossy photo quality papers are mainly swellable polymer type, and
some inks do not do well with that paper technology. I believe Canon
tends to do best with Micropore papers.

Art

Agreed. i guess that's why iP4000 has two blacks...
Regarding HP paper...i learned my lesson, i guess...
 
H

Hecate

Hasn't happened to me, at least to my Z52, which is 4 years old. Don't
know about the 5700 that preceded it, but I think the problem was a bad
cable. (Didn't worry about it since I'd bought the Z52.) I avoided Epson
becauase of all the clogged head posts, favoring long-term use, which so
far has proved true. Cartridges are expensive but go on sale at Target.
You're one of the lucky ones. Virtually every post on this ng about
Lexmark is to do with them breaking down in one way or another.
 
R

Ron Cohen

So are you saying that black isn't a color? Why else would Canon have both a
dye based black and pigmented black? Gee after all those years of owning
print shops and using black ink I never once realized that black wasn't a
color. I bet Pantone will be surprised to learn that black isn't a color.
BTW, do you know what the K in CMYK stands for?
--
Ron Cohen

Its a 3 Colour, Black is NOT a COLOUR..

The Epson R200/210 is a 5 Colour, Plus Black..
that take our breath away. (George Carlin)
 
S

SleeperMan

Ron said:
So are you saying that black isn't a color? Why else would Canon have
both a dye based black and pigmented black? Gee after all those years
of owning print shops and using black ink I never once realized that
black wasn't a color. I bet Pantone will be surprised to learn that
black isn't a color. BTW, do you know what the K in CMYK stands for?


Nice one... this link

http://www.webopedia.com/TERM/C/CMYK.html


explains that black IS a color...

BTW...i didn't know what this K means, until just now...it's stupid, really,
why it isn't B...
 
A

Arthur Entlich

B is not used for black because it is used for Blue in abbreviation.

I'm not sure how it became K, but I imagine it was first BK, but that
looked like Blue something, so they just went to K.

In light, black is the absence of color, and all colors together make
white. In dyes and pigments black is the mixture of all color, and
white is the absence of color.

Art

Ron said:
So are you saying that black isn't a color? Why else would Canon have
both a dye based black and pigmented black? Gee after all those years
of owning print shops and using black ink I never once realized that
black wasn't a color. I bet Pantone will be surprised to learn that
black isn't a color. BTW, do you know what the K in CMYK stands for?



Nice one... this link

http://www.webopedia.com/TERM/C/CMYK.html


explains that black IS a color...

BTW...i didn't know what this K means, until just now...it's stupid, really,
why it isn't B...
 
H

Hecate

Nice one... this link

http://www.webopedia.com/TERM/C/CMYK.html


explains that black IS a color...
But not really very accurate :)

Try this from Britannica:

the achromatic color of least lightness characteristically perceived
to belong to objects that neither reflect nor transmit light

and,

total or nearly total absence of light

As you see, neither agree that black is a colour precisely :)
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Top