N
Noozer
Well... I've had a chance to play with build 5384.4. Thought I'd share my
thoughts on the next incarnation of Windows.
I've been using PC's since the CP/M days. I've used OS/2. Tried BEOS and
Linux. I've done desktop support and have been a programmer. Suffices to say
that I've used MANY different computers and many different operating
systems.
The system I'm using is an Opteron 165 (dual core @ 1.8Ghz) based system
with the nVidia nForce4 chipset. 1 gig of memory and an eVGA 7600GT PCIe
video card.
Here's my list of issues that I have with Vista. It's not a complete list,
but enough to let you know what to watch for when you switch to Vista.
- "Which window is the active one?" Windows are all the same color. There is
no way to specify different colours for the active and inactive windows.
- "Where's my program?" The first thing that I did after installing Vista
was to install the Office 2007 beta. Once the installation completed I
clicked the Start button (ball?) but didn't see anything new. So I clicked
All Programs... Not in that list either? After about 20 minutes I realized
that I had to scroll the program list. There is no way that this new Start
button is going to work for most people. The text in the list is tiny and
there STILL isn't enough room for all my programs. Move the "My Computer",
"Network", etc. list to the left side of the menu and let the right side get
big enough to hold more programs... and let the groups pop open to show more
lists.
- There is ***NO*** shutdown button. Click start and you get a STANDBY
button and a LOCK this computer button. There is a tiny little button next
to these to get to the Shutdown, but I'm constantly missing it. I will
***NEVER*** lock my PC, nor use Standby. There is no way to modify these
buttons to the more useful Shutdown and Hibernate functions.
- New device detection. All you are told by Windows is that something was
found - NO indication at all if it's a Network device, soundcard,
mouse...etc. I've got a few items in my Device Mangler with the wrong
drivers installed because I didn't know what I was looking for.
- Aero... the new "glassy" interface. What is the point? First of all, being
able to see through the few pixels around the border of the window isn't
helpful at all. To make matters worse, everything under your window is
blurred beyond recognition. Also, the placement of the Minimize, Maximize
and Close buttons is just plain ugly. Looks like someone goofed. No border
above and a thick chunk of border below. They are also all different sizes
as well. UGLY.
- How many Network icons do we need in the Control Panel??? Network Center,
iSCSI, Firewall, Network Map, Network List, Network File & Printer
sharing... Why can't these all be within a SINGLE Network icon?
- Drive Mapping... How is it done? I don't have a menu bar on any of my
Explorer windows. Right clicking on a network resource doesn't give me the
Map Network Drive option.
- The User Account Control is annoying. I can understand why it's there, but
the Windows Help doesn't tell you how to disable it.
- You can't specify where you want your Gadgets. Gadgets have to be
installed on a bar, and they are top/left justified. Move them down and they
will just slide back up. On my XP system I have a nice clock that runs in
the bottom right corner of my desktop. There is no way to put the Vista
clock gadget into the lower right corner of my desktop.
....and some of the things I like about Vista...
- Gadgets. Definately an improvement from XP. They just need to get rid of
the requirement of installing them onto a "bar". I want to decide where to
put my gadgets, not have Windows stack them up in a pile.
- Operation seems smoother and more responsive than XP.
- Media Center has improved a bit. I don't have any TV tuners, so I can't
tell if recording has improved or if multiple sources are supported.
....all in all, I don't see enough improvement to go through the trouble of
working through the poor user interface changes. I'd suggest that folks
stick with XP until Vista has been out a year or two.
thoughts on the next incarnation of Windows.
I've been using PC's since the CP/M days. I've used OS/2. Tried BEOS and
Linux. I've done desktop support and have been a programmer. Suffices to say
that I've used MANY different computers and many different operating
systems.
The system I'm using is an Opteron 165 (dual core @ 1.8Ghz) based system
with the nVidia nForce4 chipset. 1 gig of memory and an eVGA 7600GT PCIe
video card.
Here's my list of issues that I have with Vista. It's not a complete list,
but enough to let you know what to watch for when you switch to Vista.
- "Which window is the active one?" Windows are all the same color. There is
no way to specify different colours for the active and inactive windows.
- "Where's my program?" The first thing that I did after installing Vista
was to install the Office 2007 beta. Once the installation completed I
clicked the Start button (ball?) but didn't see anything new. So I clicked
All Programs... Not in that list either? After about 20 minutes I realized
that I had to scroll the program list. There is no way that this new Start
button is going to work for most people. The text in the list is tiny and
there STILL isn't enough room for all my programs. Move the "My Computer",
"Network", etc. list to the left side of the menu and let the right side get
big enough to hold more programs... and let the groups pop open to show more
lists.
- There is ***NO*** shutdown button. Click start and you get a STANDBY
button and a LOCK this computer button. There is a tiny little button next
to these to get to the Shutdown, but I'm constantly missing it. I will
***NEVER*** lock my PC, nor use Standby. There is no way to modify these
buttons to the more useful Shutdown and Hibernate functions.
- New device detection. All you are told by Windows is that something was
found - NO indication at all if it's a Network device, soundcard,
mouse...etc. I've got a few items in my Device Mangler with the wrong
drivers installed because I didn't know what I was looking for.
- Aero... the new "glassy" interface. What is the point? First of all, being
able to see through the few pixels around the border of the window isn't
helpful at all. To make matters worse, everything under your window is
blurred beyond recognition. Also, the placement of the Minimize, Maximize
and Close buttons is just plain ugly. Looks like someone goofed. No border
above and a thick chunk of border below. They are also all different sizes
as well. UGLY.
- How many Network icons do we need in the Control Panel??? Network Center,
iSCSI, Firewall, Network Map, Network List, Network File & Printer
sharing... Why can't these all be within a SINGLE Network icon?
- Drive Mapping... How is it done? I don't have a menu bar on any of my
Explorer windows. Right clicking on a network resource doesn't give me the
Map Network Drive option.
- The User Account Control is annoying. I can understand why it's there, but
the Windows Help doesn't tell you how to disable it.
- You can't specify where you want your Gadgets. Gadgets have to be
installed on a bar, and they are top/left justified. Move them down and they
will just slide back up. On my XP system I have a nice clock that runs in
the bottom right corner of my desktop. There is no way to put the Vista
clock gadget into the lower right corner of my desktop.
....and some of the things I like about Vista...
- Gadgets. Definately an improvement from XP. They just need to get rid of
the requirement of installing them onto a "bar". I want to decide where to
put my gadgets, not have Windows stack them up in a pile.
- Operation seems smoother and more responsive than XP.
- Media Center has improved a bit. I don't have any TV tuners, so I can't
tell if recording has improved or if multiple sources are supported.
....all in all, I don't see enough improvement to go through the trouble of
working through the poor user interface changes. I'd suggest that folks
stick with XP until Vista has been out a year or two.