"World's Best Freeware" Site Updated... Again.

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bob Adkins
  • Start date Start date
I prefer small, quick, single function apps. It's been my experience that
programs that have 1 general function are better than programs that try to
do too many things. One doesn't normally want their calculator playing
MP3's, or their MP3 player to have a built-in spreadsheet. There are gray
areas where multi-functions make sense, if the program is well executed.

Can't totally agree on this one. Who in the right mind will design a
calc/spreadsheet in an MP3 player? A more realistic example, how about
having a VFS in a file manager? Do you think that's a bad idea?

Everyone can set his/her criteria for the "best" freeware. But I think
the criteria here definitely is too narrow...
 
I prefer small, quick, single function apps. It's been my experience that
programs that have 1 general function are better than programs that try to
do too many things. One doesn't normally want their calculator playing
MP3's, or their MP3 player to have a built-in spreadsheet. There are gray
areas where multi-functions make sense, if the program is well executed.

Using an example of calculator playing MP3 is absurd. Who in the right
mind would even think of something like that?

As MS is manily a GUI environment, "small, quick, single function apps"
are OK if the function is relatively complex, e.g. a text editor. Would
you like to use a GUI to do dir, one to do cacls, one to do rename,
etc?

I think the rating system is too narrow minded. It seems to me like a
sub-category of the whole freeware categories.
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Back
Top