WMP 10 Shuffle - Really BAD

G

Guest

I know shuffle sucked in WMP 9. And I know there are aftermarket plugins
that are designed to offer more robust shuffling features.

But seriously now, WMP 10 shuffling is horrible. I've got 10K songs, and I
usually listen to playlists of around 1000-2500. Literally, and I do mean
literally, I will hear 50 songs. I play music all day long. The same song
can come up four or five times in ONE DAY.

Now, I assume the shuffle algorithm at least partially uses the rating
system to define what it plays. However, every single song in the system has
been ranked manually, so the self-fulfilling prophecy of the more times I
accidentally hear a song I hate the more likely I am to hear it again is not
applicable.

It also appears that the machine designs a single, shuffled list, and
follows it exactly, rather than continually shuffling.

Maybe there is some settings I can tweak I don't know about?

If not, SERIOUSLY, this should be a major point of development for version
11. Give us serious shuffling tools:

Scale of 1-10

Liklihood of playing music from the same artist within X plays.
Liklihood of playing the same song in X plays.
Give preference to songs ranked highly.
Give preference to songs ranked lowly.
Give preference to songs that have been manually ranked.
Follow songs with another with similar tones, BPM, etc.

And that's just a start - I've never explored any of the aftermarket
shufflers, but I'm guessing they have some similar scales as above, plus
surely a bunch more.

Please. This would be a massive improvement to a great product.
 
Z

zachd [ms]

You don't really explain your listening scenario here.... ?
If you just quietly sit there and let WMP shuffle away, it should go from 1
to n in a random order. If you start clicking around and skipping to a
different song, as opposed to Back / Next, you're resetting the queue, I
believe.
I don't believe WMP uses any sort of weighted shuffle.

I listen to my music on WMP10 (home)/WMP11 (work) on random (20000+ My Music
playlist or my ~2500 song 4 or 5 Stars or higher (auto)playlist) and don't
run into this problem. The shuffle logic did undergo a significant beefing
up in WMP10, and I can't speak to WMP11. =)

Thanks for the feedback, though.

-Z
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Similar Threads

Shuffle repeats 2
The Zen Shuffle 2
organizing your music in WMP 1
WMP 10 -- can it edit a CD list? 12
WILL NOT FIT 2
Capacity of Audio CDs 2
playing tracks in order 1
Speakers won't work 2

Top