ftp://agn-www.informatik.uni-hamburg.de/pub/texts/tests/pc-av/2004-07/
That is a link to the latest published tests performed by the Univ. of
Hamburg
which I believe to be the most thorough independent tests available.
ftp://agn-www.informatik.uni-hamburg.de/pub/texts/tests/pc-av/
Link to all test years
Placing 1st in all categories was McAfee/Network Associates (scn)
ftp://agn-www.informatik.uni-hamburg.de/pub/texts/tests/pc-av/2004-07/0xecsum.txt
Link to the overall results.
===================== AntiVirus Products ====================
Windows-2000 (25) Windows-XP (25) LINUX(SUSE) (11)
-------------------------------------------------------------
Place 1: SCN (17) SCN (17) SCN
(16)
2: FSE (16) FSE (16)
AVP (15)
3: AVP (15) AVP (15)
FSE (13)
More: AVK,PAV (13) AVK,PAV (13) SWP (10)
NAV,RAV (11) NAV,RAV (11) FPR ( 9)
FPR ( 9) FPR ( 9)
CMD ( 8)
BDF,INO,SWP ( 8) BDF,INO,SWP ( 8) INO ( 7)
AVA,DRW ( 7) AVA,DRW ( 7) ANT ( 6)
ANT ( 6) ANT ( 6)
DRW ( 5)
AVG,CMD,PRO ( 5) AVG,CMD,PRO ( 5)
GLA,VSP ( 4) GLA,VSP ( 4)
IKA,NVC,QHL ( 3) IKA,NVC,QHL ( 3)
FIR,PER,VBR ( 2) FIR,PER,VBR ( 2)
-------------------------------------------------------------
Useless Linux AV products: CLA,OAV ( 0)
=================== AntiMalware Products ====================
Windows-2000 (25) Windows-XP (25) LINUX(SUSE) (11)
-------------------------------------------------------------
Place 1: SCN,FSE (20) SCN,FSE (20) AVP,SCN (19)
3: AVP (19) AVP (19)
FSE (17)
AVK,PAV (17) AVK,PAV (17) FPR,SWP (12)
NAV,RAV (13) RAV (14) CMD
(10)
FPR (10) NAV (13)
DRW ( 6)
BDF,INO,SWP ( 9) FPR (10)
AVA,DRW ( 8) BDF,INO,SWP ( 9)
CMD ( 7) CMD ( 7)
IKA,NVC ( 4) IKA,NVC ( 4)
VBR ( 3) VBR ( 3)
-------------------------------------------------------------
Useless Linux AV products: CLA,OAV ( 0)
Table ES2: List of AV products in test "2004-07"
================================================
Abbreviation/Product/Version Tested under Platform
----------------------------------------------------------------------
ANT = Antivir: H+B EDV Datentechnik Germany W2K WXP LIN
AVA = Avast! ALWIL Software, Czech Republic W2K WXP
AVG = AVG Antivirus System: GriSoft,Czech Republic W2K WXP
AVK = AntiVirenKit: GData Software, Germany W2K WXP
AVP = Kaspersky Anti-Virus: Kaspersky Lab. Russia W2K WXP LIN
BDF = BitDefender Professional: SOFTWIN, Romania W2K WXP
CLA = CLAM AntiVirus: Open Antivirus Project LIN
CMD = Command Antivirus:
Command Software Systems, USA W2K WXP LIN
DRW = Dr. Web: DialogueScience, Russia W2K WXP LIN
FIR = Fire Anti-virus: Prognet Technologies India W2K WXP
FPR = F-PROT: Frisk Software Intnl. Iceland W2K WXP LIN
FSE = F-SECURE: F-Secure Corporation, Finland W2K WXP LIN
GLA = Gladiator AV: Author="Gladiator" W2K WXP
IKA = Ikarus Virus Utilities:
IKARUS Software Austria W2K WXP LIN
INO = eTrust AV: Computer Associates Intnl. USA W2K WXP
NAV = Norton Antivirus: Symantec, USA W2K WXP
NVC = Norman Virus Control:
Norman Data Defense, Norway W2K WXP
OAV = Open AntiVirus: Open Antivirus Project LIN
PAV = Power AV: GData Software, Germany W2K WXP
PER = Peruvian AntiVirus: PER Systems, Peru W2K WXP
PRO = Protector: Proland Software, India W2K WXP
QHL = Qhickheal: Cat Computer Services India W2K WXP
RAV = RAV Antivirus: GeCAD Software, Romania W2K WXP
SCN = McAfee ViruScan: Network Associates, USA W2K WXP LIN
SWP = Sophos AV: Sophos, UK W2K WXP LIN
VBR = VirusBuster: Leprechaun Australia W2K WXP
VSP = VirScanPlus: Ralph Roth, Germany W2K WXP