Should I go with Vista?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dr. Palpatine
  • Start date Start date
D

Dr. Palpatine

Hi,
We are about to purchase a new PC. We have read about the many problems
with Windows Vista. We are concerned about this and wonder if we should
purchase a new PC with XP which seems to be more stable and proven. Could
anyone help us with this decision? Thanks you.

dr. p.
 
Dr. Palpatine said:
Hi,
We are about to purchase a new PC. We have read about the many problems
with Windows Vista. We are concerned about this and wonder if we should
purchase a new PC with XP which seems to be more stable and proven. Could
anyone help us with this decision? Thanks you.

dr. p.


Any new PC that comes with Vista would (presumably) have good enough
hardware to support it...
but there are still a few bugs in the OS...So I'd probably wait until SP1
comes out before going with it.

As to stability...I have *never* had even the slightest problem with XP...
so though Vista may be rock solid...I would not be able to say that it's
better
 
Windows Vista would be your best choice when preinstalled
on a new computer that is labeled "Vista Certified".

--
Carey Frisch
Microsoft MVP
Windows Shell/User

---------------------------------------------------------------

Hi,
We are about to purchase a new PC. We have read about the many problems
with Windows Vista. We are concerned about this and wonder if we should
purchase a new PC with XP which seems to be more stable and proven. Could
anyone help us with this decision? Thanks you.

dr. p.
 
I have been running it for nearly year now, and although application support
started out a bit rocky and some device drivers were still not ready, most
of my problems have been resolved over time and Vista has been rock solid
ever since. You are using the best route to purchase Windows Vista since it
will come preinstalled on a new PC that is designated Certified for Windows
Vista.
 
Why would Vista be the best choice when we have read about so many problems
with Vista? Thanks.
 
Dr. Palpatine said:
Why would Vista be the best choice when we have read about so many problems
with Vista? Thanks.

Whether or not Vista is the best OS out there is a matter for debate...
however...the best route for going with Vista would be a new machine that's
"Vista Certified"

I seriously advise you to go to a computer store and take a test drive...
as of yet...I don't think all the bugs in moving large amounts of data have
been solved.
 
What problems? If you are referring to those posted in a support newsgroup,
its like visiting a hospital. You don't see very many non-sick people laying
in a hospital bed.

--
Carey Frisch
Microsoft MVP
Windows Shell/User

---------------------------------------------------------------

:

Why would Vista be the best choice when we have read about so many problems
with Vista? Thanks.
 
Could you list some of the problems you have read about?

For me the reason I choose Vista is because its fundamentally more secure,
the multimedia experience is much richer.
- Standard User account, (this is a fundamental flaw in XP where users are
setup automatically as Full Administrator of the system, Windows Vista ends
this).
- User Account Control, rogue applications, malware, viruses cannot easily
penetrate the system

- Better ways of working with multimedia, photos, video, music is so much
better in Windows Vista and a plethora of other reasons, if you want to
learn more, read my Windows Vista review at the following link:
http://www.activewin.com/reviews/software/operating-sys/vista/
 
Dr. Palpatine said:
Hi,
We are about to purchase a new PC. We have read about the many problems
with Windows Vista. We are concerned about this and wonder if we should
purchase a new PC with XP which seems to be more stable and proven. Could
anyone help us with this decision? Thanks you.

dr. p.


Vista had an indifferent start for some, but it works well now. Most of the
negative stuff here is old news and not applicable anymore

Go with Vista..
 
Read My 2 Horror Stories About Windows XP, Service Pack 3, Release Candidate
1, Below And Then Decide Whether Buying A Windows XP OEM Computer Is Still
The Correct Choice, Just FYI. P.S. Microsoft Plans To Completely Discontinue
Windows XP Support In 2009 For Home Users, And In 2014 For Corporate Users,
Just FYI.
 
Read My 2 Horror Stories About Windows XP, Service Pack 3, Release Candidate
1, Below And Then Decide Whether Buying A Windows XP OEM Computer Is Still
The Correct Choice, Just FYI. P.S. Microsoft Plans To Completely Discontinue
Windows XP Support In 2009 For Home Users, And In 2014 For Corporate Users,
Just FYI.


First off...though you failed to provide a link... XP's SP3 has not yet been
released...
so any so called "horror" stories about a *Beta* product must be taken
without too much merit.

Secondly...though additional updates may not be avail to home users past
2009...
that hardly means that XP will be unusable.
Heck you can still take a *Win98* machine to the Windows update page and
apply all
the updates ever written for it.
 
We are about to purchase a new PC. We have read about the many problems
with Windows Vista.


Whenever a new version of *anything* comes out, you always read about
"the many problems" with it. But realize two things:

1. If you're reading about problems here in the newsgroups, this where
people come with their problems, not with their successes. You get a
very distorted view of what's going on in the real world here; as
someone once said, "hang around a transmission shop and you will think
that all cars have transmission problems."

2. Most problems, by far, that people report here have nothing to do
with defects in the software. They result from people's ignorance and
unfamiliarity with the new product, from bad or inadequate hardware,
from poor drivers, from viruses, from spyware, and so on. And except
for very rare situations, they always get a fix for their problems,
and in most cases, that fix is a very simple one to implement.

We are concerned about this and wonder if we should
purchase a new PC with XP which seems to be more stable and proven. Could
anyone help us with this decision? Thanks you.


Your choice of course. If the question were whether to upgrade your
old computer to Vista, my advice to most people is usually no. But
Vista works just fine, and for a new computer, to me there's no
question that you should get the current operating system, not
yesterday's.

Just make sure that you get adequate hardware, not the minimum that
Microsoft says Vista needs, and that you are prepared to spend some
time and effort learning and getting accustomed to the differences
between XP and Vista.
 
Philo SP1 has been out since May. Wake up. You cannot run Vista without it.
When he buys a new PC, SP1 will be there for him.
 
Dr. Palpatine said:
Hi,
We are about to purchase a new PC. We have read about the many problems
with Windows Vista. We are concerned about this and wonder if we should
purchase a new PC with XP which seems to be more stable and proven. Could
anyone help us with this decision? Thanks you.

dr. p.

stick with XP
 
AlexB said:
Philo SP1 has been out since May. Wake up. You cannot run Vista without
it. When he buys a new PC, SP1 will be there for him.

Um, SP1 has not been "out since May." In fact, it's not officially "out"
yet.

The Beta has been available, and recently RC1 was made public, but with no
support (other than newsgroups) and with no guarantees to fix anything, or
to not cause more problems, often inherent to pre-release software.

Mic
 
There are numerous people here berating Vista but if you analyze closely
what they are talking about you can see that it is a culture club. I enjoyed
reading their posts just because they are so humorous. I copied them in
drove and sent to my kids.

Their talk has nothing to do with substance. They are trolls. They are not
interested in resolving problems, they want them to be around to wallow in
them. They are dependent already on Vista troubles. When those are resolved
they will have to find another subject to bitch about. It may be hard for
some to make a transition.

If you have fairly limited demands, send email, surf the web, communicate
with friends, play music or watch a few movies you will never notice any
problem. Avoid 3-rd party software for a while unless they firmly stated, it
is Vista compatible.

If you have a lot of obscure stuff in your old XP, be careful. Some of that
may not work. Check with those who wrote it and make sure they have new
drivers.

People who buy XP now will regret it in 2 years.
 
Want to second. Very wise. Just common sense. I myself went thru it many
times. Always the first though: darn Vista, then darn me, of course quietly.
 
AlexB said:
Philo SP1 has been out since May. Wake up. You cannot run Vista without it.
When he buys a new PC, SP1 will be there for him.


'Nope you are complete wrong there SP1 has NOT been released except to Beta
testers.
You have not a clue as to what you are talking about
 
Using Windows XP Without The Latest Updates Is Much More Dangerous Then
Using Windows 98 Without The Latest Updates, Because Windows 2000, Windows
XP, And Windows Vista Are From The Windows NT Family, Where As Windows 95,
Windows 98, And Windows ME Are From The Windows 9.X Family, Just FYI.

Both The MSBlaster Virus And The Sasser Virus Can Effect Unpatched Pre-SP2
Windows XP Computers, Just FYI.
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Similar Threads


Back
Top