Steve N. said:
It's certainly getting that way. We bought a batch of PCs several months
ago that came with nearly generic OEM CDs (only diffference was the
manufacturer put their url as the default home page in IE). We just bought
another batch from them and they ship only with a "Recovery" CD now. They
aren't even a major OEM.
A "recovery" CD is not an installation CD. It contains a disk/partition
image that overwrites whatever is in the partition where you write that
image; i.e., the recovery puts you back to square one the way the host was
delivered or first setup. Data in that partition that gets "recovered" is
lost because the recovery is actually an overwrite.
It's been awhile but I recall doing a Repair from an OEM CD, but then it was
a Microsoft-branded retail OEM CD (i.e., you bought the Microsoft OEM CD
with qualifying hardware). It was not some custom or bastardized
brand-specific OEM CD, like with Dell. Even if the "recovery" CD were not
an image but an actual setup program, that doesn't mean it is the same setup
routine as provided by the Microsoft-branded install CDs. The OEM can screw
over the install anyway they want.
Make sure you are selecting the SECOND "R" option when booting from the
*install* CD. For example, in
http://support.microsoft.com/default.aspx?scid=kb;en-us;315341, in method 2,
make sure you press Enter at step 3 and not R. You need to get to the
second R selection mentioned in step 5.