H
Harvey Van Sickle
On 20 Aug 2005, John Corliss wrote
-snip-
Can you give me an example of a site which has implemented this in an
effective manner so I can test it? I use a well-known (paid-for)
recording program which sets up a virtual sound card to record anything
going through the machine (including microphone inputs for dubbing, as
well as streaming media), and so far I've never found a site where the
stream isn't captured cleanly and easily. I'd love to test it against
a known "blocking" site.
I know that Streambox was targetted, but AFAICT a quick google doesn't
find any legal action against programs like "Total Recorder". I know
that the media giants are lobbying for the US government to ban *all*
software which enables audio recording from other media, but that's
still a long way off. (They'd have to get "fair use" banned for
videos, wouldn't they?)
Actually, I don't think they *can* block it, easily or otherwise -- at
least, not the audio streams. (Video appears to be another matter.)
At the very least, I've never found an audio source that can't be
captured with the program I use.
Again, though, I'd love to do some tests against known "blocking"
sites, if you can point me to the ones you've found.
-snip-
As for saving streaming RealMedia to one's hard drive, a cursory
research on the internet has shown me that this is usually not
going to be possible for two reasons:
1. Real has incorporated proprietary coding in their media format
that blocks players which do things which Real doesn't want them
to do, like recording streaming media for instance.
Can you give me an example of a site which has implemented this in an
effective manner so I can test it? I use a well-known (paid-for)
recording program which sets up a virtual sound card to record anything
going through the machine (including microphone inputs for dubbing, as
well as streaming media), and so far I've never found a site where the
stream isn't captured cleanly and easily. I'd love to test it against
a known "blocking" site.
2. Real agressively pursues legal action against companies who put
out software for downloading streaming media.
I know that Streambox was targetted, but AFAICT a quick google doesn't
find any legal action against programs like "Total Recorder". I know
that the media giants are lobbying for the US government to ban *all*
software which enables audio recording from other media, but that's
still a long way off. (They'd have to get "fair use" banned for
videos, wouldn't they?)
This isn't to say that all RealMedia can't be saved to hard drive,
but companies who want to block this from happening can easily do
so.
Actually, I don't think they *can* block it, easily or otherwise -- at
least, not the audio streams. (Video appears to be another matter.)
At the very least, I've never found an audio source that can't be
captured with the program I use.
Again, though, I'd love to do some tests against known "blocking"
sites, if you can point me to the ones you've found.