B
Bill Pease
I've just completed a simple experiment to compare photo prints
from
my Canon i860 printer using (first) OEM original Canon inks, then
Inkgrabber.com inks and then Alotofthings.com inks in the same
printer. I wanted to find out how these two 3rdparty inks compared
with the OEM Canon inks. I thought readers of this forum might be
interested in the results of this experiment.
As the test print I chose a standard test image whose origin I failed
to note when I saved it from some printer forum on the web several
months ago. Sorry about that. It's the one with the gorgeous
girl's
eyes in the center, the church and sunset pictures at the top, the
baby's face on the right and the color samples at the bottom.
Perhaps
you recognize it from that description. It's a great test print.
First I printed this test image on my i860 Canon printer with the
original Canon inks in it. The result on letter-size Canon Photo
Paper Plus Glossy was gorgeous—perhaps just a trifle
over-saturated
for best taste, but nevertheless, gorgeous enough to melt your
insides.
Then I pulled the OEM Canon ink cartridges from the printer and
substituted Inkgrabber.com ink cartridges. I printed a full color
purge print to get all the residual Canon ink out of the printhead
and then printed the same test image as before using the
Inkgrabber.com inks. The result was lovely on the same paper, but it
differed from the OEM Canon print in the following ways:
1. the grey clock face on the OEM print had taken on a slight
greenish hue
2. the rust-colored bricks of the church on the OEM print had
turned to a dull brown
3. the blue cast of the ocean in the sundown OEM print had
turned to a greenish hue
4. the greyish-blue eyes of the gorgeous girl in the OEM print
had turned to greenish-blue, her skin had turned very pale, and her
eyebrows had turned from brown to greenish-grey
5. the grey-to-black picture of the man in the OEM print had
turned to green-to-black.
In conclusion, the print produced using the Inkgrabber.com ink
cartridges differed considerably from the print produced using the
OEM Canon ink cartridges. Nevertheless, the Inkgrabber.com cartridges
produced a lovely print that might please some even though it did not
duplicate exactly the colors of the OEM Canon print. The
Inkgrabber.com ink cartridges for the Canon i860 printer cost about
$2.00 each.
Then I pulled the Inkgrabber.com cartridges from my printer and
substituted Alotofthings.com cartridges. Again I printed a full color
purge print to get all the residual Inkgrabber ink out of the
printhead and then printed the same test image as before using the
Alotofthings.com inks. The result was gorgeous on the same paper,
ALMOST identical to the OEM Canon print. It differed, ever so
slightly, in the following ways:
1. the grey clock face in the OEM print was just slightly tan
2. the grey parallel lines in the OEM print were just slightly
tan
3. the gorgeous girl's skin tone in the OEM print was just
slightly lighter
4. the grey-to-black picture of the man in the OEM print was
just slightly a little tan.
I would emphasize the word "slightly" here; you had to look
REAL hard
at the print done using Alotofthings.com cartridges to discern any
difference from the print done using OEM Canon cartridges. And the
OEM Canon cartridges cost about $11-$12 each. The Alotofthings.com
cartridges cost me $2.40 each (including postage) when I bought an
i860 combo package that included 18 cartridges of the 5 different
ones for the i860.
I'm not a photo purist (or a pro) who would quibble about the
VERY
slight differences between the OEM Canon print and the
Alotofthings.com print, but I am a retired realist who can appreciate
the fact that the Alotofthings.com cartridges cost one-fifth of what
the OEM Canon cartridges cost while producing gorgeous prints that
are ALMOST identical to the OEM Canon prints. Alotofthings.com is
going to get my cartridge business from now on. I'm going to
print
all my photos and a couple of family history books with them.
By the way, Alotofthings.com also sells bulk ink and paraphernalia
for refillers too. With superb cartridges for just $2.40 each,
though, I can't see much sense to go through the trouble of
refilling
cartridges with all its hassle.
Others may want to.
And I am in no way connected with anybody or anything at
Alotofthings.com except as a happy and very satisfied customer.
Here are the relevant web addresses:
http://www.inkgrabber.com/index.htm
http://www.alotofthings.com/index.html
Happy printing,
Bill Pease
from
my Canon i860 printer using (first) OEM original Canon inks, then
Inkgrabber.com inks and then Alotofthings.com inks in the same
printer. I wanted to find out how these two 3rdparty inks compared
with the OEM Canon inks. I thought readers of this forum might be
interested in the results of this experiment.
As the test print I chose a standard test image whose origin I failed
to note when I saved it from some printer forum on the web several
months ago. Sorry about that. It's the one with the gorgeous
girl's
eyes in the center, the church and sunset pictures at the top, the
baby's face on the right and the color samples at the bottom.
Perhaps
you recognize it from that description. It's a great test print.
First I printed this test image on my i860 Canon printer with the
original Canon inks in it. The result on letter-size Canon Photo
Paper Plus Glossy was gorgeous—perhaps just a trifle
over-saturated
for best taste, but nevertheless, gorgeous enough to melt your
insides.
Then I pulled the OEM Canon ink cartridges from the printer and
substituted Inkgrabber.com ink cartridges. I printed a full color
purge print to get all the residual Canon ink out of the printhead
and then printed the same test image as before using the
Inkgrabber.com inks. The result was lovely on the same paper, but it
differed from the OEM Canon print in the following ways:
1. the grey clock face on the OEM print had taken on a slight
greenish hue
2. the rust-colored bricks of the church on the OEM print had
turned to a dull brown
3. the blue cast of the ocean in the sundown OEM print had
turned to a greenish hue
4. the greyish-blue eyes of the gorgeous girl in the OEM print
had turned to greenish-blue, her skin had turned very pale, and her
eyebrows had turned from brown to greenish-grey
5. the grey-to-black picture of the man in the OEM print had
turned to green-to-black.
In conclusion, the print produced using the Inkgrabber.com ink
cartridges differed considerably from the print produced using the
OEM Canon ink cartridges. Nevertheless, the Inkgrabber.com cartridges
produced a lovely print that might please some even though it did not
duplicate exactly the colors of the OEM Canon print. The
Inkgrabber.com ink cartridges for the Canon i860 printer cost about
$2.00 each.
Then I pulled the Inkgrabber.com cartridges from my printer and
substituted Alotofthings.com cartridges. Again I printed a full color
purge print to get all the residual Inkgrabber ink out of the
printhead and then printed the same test image as before using the
Alotofthings.com inks. The result was gorgeous on the same paper,
ALMOST identical to the OEM Canon print. It differed, ever so
slightly, in the following ways:
1. the grey clock face in the OEM print was just slightly tan
2. the grey parallel lines in the OEM print were just slightly
tan
3. the gorgeous girl's skin tone in the OEM print was just
slightly lighter
4. the grey-to-black picture of the man in the OEM print was
just slightly a little tan.
I would emphasize the word "slightly" here; you had to look
REAL hard
at the print done using Alotofthings.com cartridges to discern any
difference from the print done using OEM Canon cartridges. And the
OEM Canon cartridges cost about $11-$12 each. The Alotofthings.com
cartridges cost me $2.40 each (including postage) when I bought an
i860 combo package that included 18 cartridges of the 5 different
ones for the i860.
I'm not a photo purist (or a pro) who would quibble about the
VERY
slight differences between the OEM Canon print and the
Alotofthings.com print, but I am a retired realist who can appreciate
the fact that the Alotofthings.com cartridges cost one-fifth of what
the OEM Canon cartridges cost while producing gorgeous prints that
are ALMOST identical to the OEM Canon prints. Alotofthings.com is
going to get my cartridge business from now on. I'm going to
all my photos and a couple of family history books with them.
By the way, Alotofthings.com also sells bulk ink and paraphernalia
for refillers too. With superb cartridges for just $2.40 each,
though, I can't see much sense to go through the trouble of
refilling
cartridges with all its hassle.
Others may want to.
And I am in no way connected with anybody or anything at
Alotofthings.com except as a happy and very satisfied customer.
Here are the relevant web addresses:
http://www.inkgrabber.com/index.htm
http://www.alotofthings.com/index.html
Happy printing,
Bill Pease