J
John John (MVP)
I guess it's no that either. Maybe links to censored porn
John
John
John said:Lets see if this will work:
Whether you agree with Alias or not one can safely say that his posts
never contain spam, porn, links to porn or vulgar language, yet many of
his posts have been removed or prevented from ever appearing on the MS
servers. On broaching the issue of the practice of shipping computers
with "restorations" cd's and recovery partitions instead of real Windows
cds I have had posts censored in these groups, so I know that some
things are sensitive to someone at Microsoft, there are just some
subjects that someone at Microsoft doesn't like seeing aired out in
public! Other than that Microsoft is quite tolerant of what is being
said in these groups (on their servers), even when it is inflammatory or
highly critical of Microsoft.
John
Daave said:Surely someone from Microsoft is removing the posts. But that doesn't
make this a moderated newsgroup (strictly speaking). Posts on moderated
newsgroups do not show up immediately. They are *all* reviewed first.
That is why 4PeaceMirelle's silly post showed up (because this is not a
moderated newsgroup). And that is why Alias's posts show up (and
propagate and get archived on Google, etc., even if they are removed
from the MS news server shortly after they are posted). If this group
were moderated (again, in the generally accepted Usenet sense of the
term), Alias's posts (and presumably 4PeaceMirelle's claptrap) would not
show up in the first place and would therefore not propagate.
Ron said:I have been posting in these newsgroups since 1996 and I have never seen nor
heard of a post intentionally taken off a MS server merely because there
were discussions of or rants about MS. Posts are removed upon the request
of the poster if there is a valid reason, if they contain blatant spam,
contain excessive profanity, have any reference to porn, could contain
dangerous info, etc. MS takes freedom of speech very seriously and does not
arbitrarily remove posts just because they are critical of MS. With that
said, I don't recall seeing posts made by Alias so I don't know what might
be objectionable in his posts if they are indeed being removed. I would
also be willing to bet that a person could lose his/her job at MS if he/she
removed a post because of a grudge.
Alias said:Many, many times my posts never show up in the first place.
Daave said:This one did!
John said:Maybe because he didn't post anything controversial. But one of my post
won't make it to the servers... unless I post it in Morse Code! lol I
wonder what is in the post that forbids it on the servers.
Mind you, I don't think that anyone is saying that anything and
everything should be allowed here, else we would have to wade through
tons of spam and f*r*e*e s\e\x junk, as is often the case on .alt
discussion groups. There has to be filtering and post removal going on
or else the groups would be swamped and everyone would be extremely
annoyed. But I think that along with the necessary filtering and post
removal someone is applying "other" rules of their own.
John
Fwiw, a couple days ago I saw a warning in the vista general group fromJohn said:Maybe because he didn't post anything controversial. But one of my post
won't make it to the servers... unless I post it in Morse Code! lol I
wonder what is in the post that forbids it on the servers.
Mind you, I don't think that anyone is saying that anything and
everything should be allowed here, else we would have to wade through
tons of spam and f*r*e*e s\e\x junk, as is often the case on .alt
discussion groups. There has to be filtering and post removal going on
or else the groups would be swamped and everyone would be extremely
annoyed. But I think that along with the necessary filtering and post
removal someone is applying "other" rules of their own.
John
Alan said:Alias,
What's REALLY scary is that Microsoft is actually paying people to
administer their newsgroups, to keep 'subversives' like you off the air.
Alan
John said:Maybe because he didn't post anything controversial. But one of my
post won't make it to the servers... unless I post it in Morse Code!
lol I wonder what is in the post that forbids it on the servers.
Mind you, I don't think that anyone is saying that anything and
everything should be allowed here, else we would have to wade through
tons of spam and f*r*e*e s\e\x junk, as is often the case on .alt
discussion groups. There has to be filtering and post removal going
on or else the groups would be swamped and everyone would be extremely
annoyed. But I think that along with the necessary filtering and post
removal someone is applying "other" rules of their own.
Daave said:This one did!
Correction. The thread is "adam albright's dream fantasy...LOL!", notnorm said:Fwiw, a couple days ago I saw a warning in the vista general group from
Colin Barnhorst about some drastic actions forthcoming in the groups
concerning posts deemed inappropriate. The thread is "the powers that be".
"Colin Barnhorst wrote:
Suggestion: I really wish you guys would move on from this Adam
NotSoBright stuff. It is entirely off-topic and is starting to result
in some ugly looking actions from the powers-that-be."
Quite possibly, Colin might have more info on what specifically is going
on.
Daave said:Most of Alias's posts are not controversial. Apparently, when he changed
his e-mail address, his posts started showing up again, so MS was
filtering all posts including that old address. My guess is they don't
appreciate it when he gives people instructions on how to transfer an
OEM license from one PC to another.
I changed my email address and Carey Frisch isn't up yet.
Daave said:Does Carey Frisch have the ability to remove/filter your posts?
Alan said:Well, this public newsgroup is moderated enough such that posts from 'Alias'
are deleted almost as soon as they are posted.
Alias REALLY must have pissed someone at Microsoft off for them to be doing
that.
Alan
Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?
You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.