Can't argue with anything you said... I concur totally, I am sure thatI am
going to get the 'split' you referenced but kinda hoped that someone out
there resolved this to a specific response from MS or some authority. Thc...
This is Windows XP (Setup and Deployment) support - not legal support. ;-)
You would be better off asking a legal expert in your specific part of the
world - someone whose credentials you know to be those of a legal expert vs.
a software installation and troubleshooting expert.
An Internet search will not really broaden your knowledge on the topic - as
you will see basically the same split you claim to be getting from said
"suppliers". In the end - I can say I don't recall any cases of Microsoft
pinpointing a single consumer and asking them for proof their OEM license of
Windows XP came with some piece of hardware. Not saying the supplierthat
sold it to them did/did not include said hardware or if what said supplier
did was legal/illegal - just what I have/have not seen.
The usual requirement to obtain an OEM version is to purchase a "core"
system component. Core components are usually required to run
Windows, such as:
-- motherboard
-- hard drives
-- optical (CD/DVD) drives
-- RAM
It has been noted that several "questionable" bundles may have
encluded:
power cable
internal cable(s)
keyboard
mice
But of course, this is usually "subject" to change depending on your
"local laws" and Microsoft's judgement.