I do understand how some of you feel about it, but, what you don't
seem to understand is that you have other options if you don't like
what it does. You licensed XP for use, you don't own it, you don't
really know what it's doing when you're online, your firewall may not
really be telling you everything.... You don't really know what's in
the Windows updates that you're installing....
That's the problem. See below.
Since it's an automated process you don't really have to "Keep
proving" anything, it just happens without you needing to do
anything, so, if you trust microsoft enough to use their OS, you
should trust them enough to let their OS phone home....
This is not about trust, Leythos.
Microsoft has the corner on the market in the community of which I am
reluctantly a part. Although I do have a choice about what I use at
home, it's inconvenient to be on a different platform.
I use Microsoft's product, just like any other product, because it does
what I need it to do. Some of the time, anyway.
If Microsoft were a pharmaceutical company, a cosmetic company, a large
manufacturer of consumer goods, or an automobile manufacturer, trust
would not be the issue we're discussing. Full disclosure is required,
and in the absence of full disclosure, I would have the basis of a
lawsuit. These companies are required to let me, the consumer, know what
their product will do and what it don't do. And if the product fails to
work /as represented by the company/, I can sue, and I will probably
prevail. Read a cosmetic label sometime, and see the way they dance
around the claims--because they are bound by the claims they make. Most
labeling doesn't really have a whole lot of content, so one does need to
read and comprehend what the actual claims for the product are--but the
claims and disclosures must be made to the consumer. It's the law.
You'd best believe that if I had to dance around like this to use a tube
of mascara, I would find an alternative, or I'd give up mascara. It's
not as easy to get a different operating system or give up computers
entirely.
What if you had to call Makita every time you wanted to use its radial
arm saw? What if you had to call Detroit (or Japan or some other
country) every time you wanted to go to the store? What are you going to
do when your boxer shorts start phoning home to Fruit of the Loom?
I'll tell you...I always knew skydiving could kill me, because both my
rig and my canopy said so, in big bold black letters on an bright orange
label. The gear manufacturers also say, very plainly, that the gear can
fail for no reason. Skydiving gear is always in beta, but what you don't
seem to take into account is that even when Microsoft says it's not
beta, it is. It's never "the final product" because there's always
something else Microsoft needs to do, but that's never what we're told,
and then we have to deal with the consequences.
If there is to be trust of any kind, it exists in a climate of full
disclosure. I don't see that. In the meantime, I've got that stupid
little WGA thingie doing the same thing each time I boot up, and I want
to know why it needs to check up on me all the time. Not once, Leythos,
but every time I reboot the computer.
Where's the sense in that?
--
Rhonda Lea Kirk
Insisting on perfect safety is for people
without the balls to live in the real world.
Mary Shafer Iliff