My latest Dell has 6 USB 2.0 ports. But no 1394!
I'd prefer to have 4 USBs and 2 FWs instead.
This distinction seems to apply to digicams and cameras: my 2 Sony
camcorders both have Firewire to download to PCs. My cameras all have USB
download.
Could someone explain why this is so? I am sure there are good reasons
behind all this.
Thanks.
Good reasons? Maybe, it depends on if your're an accountant or not. In
engineering terms, there's no good reason why not. But in accounting terms
it's a much different story.
Simple economics of scale.
USB 2 is "in the chipset" so therefore it cost nothing to "include" in a
PC other then a connector and maybe some addional misc. parts.
Firewire requires more chips than just the basic shipset.
So it you're making millions of motherboards or PCs, then the extre 3 or 4
bucks for the chip add up to a,ot of money. I met a guy who used to design
Intel motherboards for mass market PCs and asked him why they didn't put
more than just a couple of DIMM sockets on them and he asid "they won;t
let us because that would add an extra 25-cents" - it would add hundreds
of thousands of dollarns to the cost of the production with no return.
Fortunately if you build your own or if you're willing to pay for more than
a basic PC and shop around you can get ready made PCs with Firewire. I saw
some nice PC's on sale in a Radio Shack one day with a nice little door on
the front panel with Firewire connectors.
If you want to see more PC's with Firewire support - buy one with it
included. Voting with your dollars sends a powerful message. When you
shop, tell the salesman you'll only buy one with Firewire. Write to Dell,
HP, IBM, etc and tell them you want it. Write to Intel en-masse and demand
Firewire support in the chipset. There's no reason in the world that
Intel can;t do this - they have *radios* in their chipsets, so Firewire
should be painless for them!
But then Intel developed USB2 to compete with Firewire, so it's a
political issue with them more than anything else. Intel knows that video
is a killer app, so demand Firewire. If enough people demand it,
eventually they'll respond.
You bought a Dell - you bought it online, yes? Didn't the customization
screen give you an option of a Firewire card? If not, call Dell and
complain -but don't complain to the first person that answers the phone,
demand to speak to a sales manager.
But if you're really smart, just open the case and plug in a $20 Firewire
card and don't depend on someone else to build it for you. It's sdimple
and painless and there's no drivers to load, it just works.
--Keith