In Uncle Grumpy had this to say:
My reply is at the bottom of your sent message:
Got a card bus slot? You can purchase a 2.0 card quite reasonably.
I almost suggested that but - and pardon my ignorance - I didn't want to
make a boo-boo.
So, well, would it be any good? I guess what I don't know is the max
transfer speed for PCMCIA slots as compared to USB 1.1 or 2.0...
I did a wee bit of homework just to see. (I really didn't know the answer
which is why I ask as I still don't know the answer. I keep finding
conflicting information.)
- 32 bit PCMCIA (CardBus) specs have a max throughput of 132 Mb/sec (As near
as I can tell though there are a bunch of vendors seemingly claiming full
USB 2.0 spec throughput and FireWire throughput.)
- USB 1.1 is only 12 Mb/sec which is a lot slower than the PCMCIA standard
allows.
- USB 2.0 specs 480 Mb/sec.
There would, I'm guessing, be quite an improvement in speed but nothing near
the burst rates of USB 2.0 so the question begs, is it really worth it? An
even more looming question is, am I over-tired and missing something? (You
seem a knowledgeable fellow, I figured I'd tap you for an answer if you had
one.)
What I find annoying is the manufacturers and maybe I'm missing something
but even with a Type III or even the 2.1 standards the maximum throughput is
(optimized for synchronous burst-transfer) only 132 Mb/sec and the "PC Card"
(16 bit version based on the ISA bus) is good for 160 Mb/sec and yet vendors
of the devices (PCMCIA/PC Card to USB 2.0 and FireWire 1394b, rated at 800
Mb/sec) claim full throughput. Are they just neglecting to mention the
bottleneck, does the bottleneck not exist, or is it just a creative market
spin allowed because no one bothers to check? (I should probably check, they
probably clearly say "speeds up to" in the fine print buried on page 17 and
I just missed it but even if it says "up to" there's no way it can reach
those speeds unless I'm missing something.)
--
Galen - MS MVP - Windows (Shell/User & IE)
http://dts-l.org/ http://kgiii.info/
"Chance has put in our way a most singular and whimsical problem, and
its solution is its own reward." - Sherlock Holmes