Replies - Alex Nichol

  • Thread starter Thread starter Don
  • Start date Start date
D

Don

This may be complete nonsense but it's been bothering me for a while.
Whenever a read a post from Alex Nichol in this group he seems to be
replying to a question from another user. What happens to the original
post??? It never seems to be here?
 
Alex is located in the UK and has a Dial Up connection. As with many people
on Dial up he likely downloads messages from a newsgroup and then replies to
them off line to save connection costs finally uploading his replies later
when he reconnects. Alex generally retains the original post in his
responses.
 
Hi, Don.

As you probably know, this is a VERY active newsgroup. I show 43,000+
messages here since 10/11/04, or an average of over 700 per day. If you
haven't changed OE's default settings, you are getting only 300 headers at a
time; if you sign on just once a day, you are missing over half the posts
here. That may be why you might sometimes download MVP Alex's answers to
questions that you did not download. Of if you have OE set to delete
messages too soon, the question may disappear before Alex's answer appears.
(Alex lives in England. He has explained elsewhere that he usually
downloads a large batch of messages, reads them and prepares replies, then
sends the replies as a batch; this sometimes results in a delay of perhaps a
day or more. This explains, too, why you may sometimes see his reply that
seems to echo an earlier response: he prepared his reply before the other
response was posted.) So the combination of time-zone difference and his
batch-mode participation - and your OE settings - might explain what you are
seeing. I've learned that Alex's answers are worth waiting for. ;<)

OE is customizable in many ways. Click Tools | Options... On the Read tab,
under News, you can change the setting for Get ___ headers at a time, from
the default 300 to as many as 1,000 - or uncheck the box (as I did) to get
ALL the headers. (Be prepared for a long wait the first time you visit the
NG after this; even with broadband it takes a while to get them all.) On
the Maintenance tab, increase the setting for Delete news messages ___ days
after being downloaded; the default (5, as I recall) may be too short for
the way YOU read the newsgroups. I have this set to 32 days. If you have
this at just 1 day, for example, OE may be deleting the questions from your
Message Store before Alex's reply arrives. And you can set individual
newsgroups to download All Messages, New Messages Only or Headers Only.
Here again, be prepared for a long session the first time you synchronize a
busy NG with All Messages set, but you won't miss parts of a thread.

One more possibility is that you are accessing this newsgroup through some
news server other than "the mother ship". These Microsoft public newsgroups
(also known as Discussion Groups in Microsoft Communities when accessed via
the Web-based interface) are hosted by the Microsoft news server, which is
free and does not require a logon. Other news servers simply "slurp"
messages from here and relay them - and replies - back and forth, often
resulting in messages that are delayed, out of sequence, or simply lost. If
you are using your ISP's news server to read this NG, try setting up a News
Account in OE for msnews.microsoft.com, and subscribing to your choices of
the 2000+ MS public NGs through that server.

RC
 
Alex is located in the UK and has a Dial Up connection. As with many people
on Dial up he likely downloads messages from a newsgroup and then replies to
them off line to save connection costs finally uploading his replies later
when he reconnects. Alex generally retains the original post in his
responses.

Alex still on dial-up? I believe he is now on broadband, although I
believe your description of how he manages newsgroups is accurate.
--
Tom Porterfield
MS-MVP Windows
http://support.telop.org

Please post all follow-ups to the newsgroup only.
 
I would guess that he is hitting "New Post" instead of "Reply Group"
And then keying in "RE:******" ???
 
| On Fri, 10 Dec 2004 08:30:13 -0600, Harry Ohrn wrote:
|
| > Alex is located in the UK and has a Dial Up connection. As with many
people
| > on Dial up he likely downloads messages from a newsgroup and then
replies to
| > them off line to save connection costs finally uploading his replies
later
| > when he reconnects. Alex generally retains the original post in his
| > responses.
|
| Alex still on dial-up? I believe he is now on broadband, although I
| believe your description of how he manages newsgroups is accurate.
| --
| Tom Porterfield
| MS-MVP Windows
| http://support.telop.org
|
| Please post all follow-ups to the newsgroup only.

Yes a bit presumptuous on my part :-)
 
Hi, Tim.

A lot of newbies make that mistake, but Alex would not. See the other
replies.

RC
 
Don said:
This may be complete nonsense but it's been bothering me for a while.
Whenever a read a post from Alex Nichol in this group he seems to be
replying to a question from another user. What happens to the original
post??? It never seems to be here?

Because of time zone effects, my replies may well be quite a time delay
after the question was posted. My guess would be that you have OE set
to its default of getting only the most recent 300 posts, and are
missing more than half the posts actually made in a day (which is
typically 800 or 900 in this group). So you see the reply but miss the
question. If you are accessing the group regularly I suggest you turn
that off in Tools - Options - Read.

And to others, speculating on my methods, I am on broadband, and do not
batch replies. But in the nature of things, with most posters being in
US. when I download new messages in the morning there are enough to
occupy me most of the day, and if I *do* get another batch in late
afternoon, there are not very many new ones
 
Alex Nichol said:
Because of time zone effects, my replies may well be quite a time delay
after the question was posted. My guess would be that you have OE set
to its default of getting only the most recent 300 posts, and are
missing more than half the posts actually made in a day (which is
typically 800 or 900 in this group). So you see the reply but miss the
question. If you are accessing the group regularly I suggest you turn
that off in Tools - Options - Read.

And to others, speculating on my methods, I am on broadband, and do not
batch replies. But in the nature of things, with most posters being in
US. when I download new messages in the morning there are enough to
occupy me most of the day, and if I *do* get another batch in late
afternoon, there are not very many new ones

You're right. I guess I've been missing a lot. Have changed it now.
Thanks.
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Similar Threads

Alex Nichol / Posts 11
What happened to Alex Nichol? 3
FAT32 to NTFS - Re: Alex Nichol (MVP) paper 12
To Kelly... 2
Alex Nichol...RIP 1
Tweakui 7
Andre Da Costa where are you? 4
Connection speed restored 2

Back
Top