Poor audio quality using music track with WMM 2.1

G

Guest

I'm an absolute beginner at video. I'm trying to make a decent movie from DV
footage (Canon Optura 50) and WMM 2.1 My first movie has an audio track made
of a music song encoded in mp3 (192 kbps) and no footage sound (silenced).
The outcome is saved in AVI-DV in order tu later burn a DVD. While the video
is great, sound is of poor quality and noticeably distorted (sort of poor
dinamics and reverberation). However, if I play the project in WMM sounds
great! I play the movie and the songtrack with WMP. Seems to me that there is
an audio encoding problem within WMM.

Could yo help me? Thank for your support and patience.

Best regards.
 
G

Guest

Thanks, Graham, for your ansxer.

I did try wav and wma versions of the same soundtrack; the outcome is the
same. I also tried different, more compressed clip outputs, all yielding
worse video output (as expected) but far more better audio quality. The only
clip format that exhibits such poor audio quality is DV-AVI (PAL). I'm
running WXP home SP2, spanish version. My codec listing is as follows:

IMA ADPCM
MIcrosft ADPCM
MIcrosoft CCITT.G711
MIcrosoft GSM 6.10
DSP Group Truespeech
MSG723.acm
Windows Media Audio
Spiro Lab Telecom
Fraunhofer IIS MPEG Layer-3
Dvacm.acm
Indeo audio software
Conversor PCM de Microsoft

I'm really puzzled about this. Searching this forum and other Internet video
resources, I haven't found anything like this.

Best Regards.
--
Amando Hernádnez
www.imagenlibre.com


Graham Hughes said:
MM doesn't like mp3's, use a wma/wmv/wav instead, should then work.
Graham

--
Graham Hughes
MVP Digital Media
www.myvideoproblems.co.uk
www.dvds2treasure.com
www.simplydv.com
Click to expand...
 
G

Guest

In order to show what the problem looks like, I have made an example clip
(just a few seconds) and saved in two different formats: compressed wmv and
AVI-DV. You can have a look at:

http://www.imagenlibre.com/video/Audio-problem.wmv
http://www.imagenlibre.com/video/Audio-problem-DV-PAL.avi

The first one has the soundtrack right. The second one (just a few seconds
due to server space constraints) has a defective soundtrack. Please, use
headphones yo appreciate sound differences.

The sound comes from a wma ripped from the original CD.

Thanks for trying to help. Best regards.
--
Amando Hernádnez
www.imagenlibre.com


amando said:
Thanks, Graham, for your ansxer.

I did try wav and wma versions of the same soundtrack; the outcome is the
same. I also tried different, more compressed clip outputs, all yielding
worse video output (as expected) but far more better audio quality. The only
clip format that exhibits such poor audio quality is DV-AVI (PAL). I'm
running WXP home SP2, spanish version. My codec listing is as follows:

IMA ADPCM
MIcrosft ADPCM
MIcrosoft CCITT.G711
MIcrosoft GSM 6.10
DSP Group Truespeech
MSG723.acm
Windows Media Audio
Spiro Lab Telecom
Fraunhofer IIS MPEG Layer-3
Dvacm.acm
Indeo audio software
Conversor PCM de Microsoft

I'm really puzzled about this. Searching this forum and other Internet video
resources, I haven't found anything like this.

Best Regards.
Click to expand...
 
G

Guest

Thanks, Graham, for your answer.

Well, I don't think so (of course, one is never sure of that). My PC is CPU
idle before generating the clip. It has 1 GB memory, P4 3GHz HT processor and
defragmented SATA disk. That the outcome is consistent (same audio quality
all over the clip and on several clips) makes me belive that the problem lies
on software rather than hw resources.

Best regards.
 
G

Guest

Graham, I've visite your web page My Video Problems. Good content, clearly
laid out. Congrats!

Best regards
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Similar Threads

Audio Quality Poor on DVD 1
Problem with Audio/Music Track 3
Shift audio track vs video track using Windows Movie Maker - possible? 4
Importing/Output Quality Issue 2
poor video and audio with the final .wmv 4
no one with MPG problems with WMM 2.1?? 12
I lose video when I add an audio/music track. 6
audio glitch at transition points with DV-AVI 3

Top