D
David Maynard
Folkert said:Please learn to post.
That depends on whether their drives actually do support the Format Track command.
No it doesn't as writing zeroes is writing zeros regardless of what other
commands the drive may support.
If the drives don't then obviously 'they' don't do a Low Level Format.
And they don't.
If the drives do support it, it doesn't necessarily mean 'they' use it too.
Correct, which is why your first claim is nonsense.
Plus, they don't.
And since you can't change sector size and sectors per track with IDE there will be no
real formatting taking place anyway.
This, of course, is the same thing as saying they don't do formatting so
after all that gibberish you've restated what I said to begin with.
And what exactly do you think a Low Level Format would do differently?
A low level format.
Btw, that sentence doesn't even make sense when taken literally.
It does to those familiar with English.
Has nothing to do with modern (IDE) drives.
With all drives the 'format' is done at the factory, none excluded.
False. I've had plenty of drives that came unformatted. Of course, they
weren't modern drives.
You have to go back a long way to where drives came without the drive
controller and you had to low level format it depending on what controller
you were using.
That, of course, is the meaning of (not) 'modern drives'.
But even these drives were preformatted in the factory.
False.
Still, even IDE drives allowed LLF-ing after they became obsolete and
it was actually possible to kill a drive by using the wrong parameters
or breaking off an ongoing LLF.
Not modern ones.
Yes it is,
Shall we quote you? "And since you can't change sector size and sectors per
track with IDE there will be no real formatting taking place anyway."
except that there is no point in doing it, with the drive
already formatted and not being allowed to change sector size.
You can't 'change' it because you can't low level format the drive.
IBM/Hitachi drives do allow reformatting of LBA to Physical location
translation.
'Translation' isn't formatting.
SCSI drives still allow Low Level Formatting.
Not on any modern SCSI drive I am aware of.