Woodchuck said:
I purchased a Maxtor 250g which includes their ATA133 PCI board. The
question is since my MB supports ATA100 is there much of a performance if I
don't use the Maxtor board? The new drive will be installed as "D" since
some of my software installed on "C" is registered and references to
something on the drive to run. I have tried to move the software to another
drive and it' will not run. The new drive will be used mainly for video
editing and so far I have had no issues with the present ATA100 drive. Just
needed more space...
We've gone a few rounds on this subject matter in the
alt.comp.periphs.mainboard.asus newsgroup. That discussion relates to
theP4C800-E Deluxe motherboard, but it might apply to your question, as
well. That mb has onboard ATA100, and also a Promise RAID controller that
can be run as an ATA133 IDE host adapter (non-raid). I (and others) have run
benchmarks that have shown remarkable results. I'm going to cite mine below,
but if you wish to see the remaining posts in this thread, check into the
asus newsgroup.
XP Pro SP1 with 4GB PC2100 and P4-1600 (HD Tach 2.7):
Western Digital 200GB 8M cache boot drive on IDE port:
Random access: 13.8ms
Read burst speed: 28.1MB/s
Read speed average 26.4 MB/s
CPU Utilization: 5.3%
Maxtor 250GB 8M cache drive on Promise port (non-raid):
Random access: 14.3ms
Read burst speed: 106.1MB/s
Read speed average 50.3 MB/s
CPU Utilization: 5.4%
Seagate ST318452LW 15k on LSI Logic U/160:
Random access: 5.9ms
Read burst speed: 82.3MB/s
Read speed average 55.5MB/s
CPU Utilization: 5.9%
COMMENT: The difference between similar drives on the IDE and Promise
controllers is astonishing, almost hard to believe. Burst speed even exceeds
the 15k drive. Of course, no IDE can get close to a 15k hard drive for
random access.
I also have a Maxtor Atlas 15k 73GB hard drive, one of the world's fastest
drive's, to be installed (storagereview.com). This setup is for video
editing. A two hour avi exported from an 8MM tape is around 25GB, too large
for my Seagate 15k, thus, the Atlas.