VGA Silencer

D

dorkus.erectus

I have an Arctic-Cooling VGA Silencer rev.3 attached to my Sapphire 9800
Pro.
It works great for me but I've heard/read lately that this thing is a
possible cause of killing some people's videocards.
Could it be that maybe some users are clamping down the screws too hard?
I'm just looking for the latest opinions on this. And maybe a tip to the
"best" forum.

Thanks,
Rick
 
D

DrWho

dorkus.erectus said...
I have an Arctic-Cooling VGA Silencer rev.3 attached to my Sapphire 9800
Pro.
It works great for me but I've heard/read lately that this thing is a
possible cause of killing some people's videocards.

Really? Please tell us where you've heard that.

I put one on my 9700 non-pro - allowed me to overclock it to 375MHz,
where the stock speed is 275 MHz. I LOVE my VGA Silencer!

--
DrWho

Abit KX7-333R
XP2700/333
1GB Corsair XMS PC3200 CAS 2.0
ATI 9700non-pro (CPU:375 Mem:303)
Two 80GB WD 7200/8MB in a RAID0
 
M

Mike

dorkus.erectus said...
Well its taking an awful long time to kill my 9800pro, its been on for more than
6 months.

This cooler is one of my better purchases, practical, very quiet, and definitely
a cooler gpu.


Mike
 
N

Noozer

dorkus.erectus said...

Really? Please tell us where you've heard that.

I put one on my 9700 non-pro - allowed me to overclock it to 375MHz,
where the stock speed is 275 MHz. I LOVE my VGA Silencer!

I've heard a few stories as well... Card seems fine, nice and cool, no
problems... then one day it doesn't work.

Had it happen to me with my 9600XT. Put the ATI sink back on and it came
back to life.

Normally I'd just say it was a bad installation, but I was very careful and
checked it over before installing and again when it failed.

My friends 9800Pro is quite noisy so I'm thinking about selling it to him,
but I don't know if it's worth the risk.
 
M

Mike

I've heard a few stories as well... Card seems fine, nice and cool, no
problems... then one day it doesn't work.

Had it happen to me with my 9600XT. Put the ATI sink back on and it came
back to life.

Normally I'd just say it was a bad installation, but I was very careful and
checked it over before installing and again when it failed.

My friends 9800Pro is quite noisy so I'm thinking about selling it to him,
but I don't know if it's worth the risk.

More likely due to using too much artic silver compound. I have come across
cases where too much A/S was used and it has shot out when hot due to capillary
action similar to an inkjet printer. Once the cpu was brushed thoroughly with a
soft brush using isopropyl all was well again. I cannot think of anything else
that would stop your card from running, other than total stupidity of course...
such as over tightening the 2 pressure bolts. BTW the instructions state to
tighten down those bolts until the gap is taken up between the rubber spacers,
IMO this results in lots more pressure being required than is really
necessary.... too much IMO. To remove the space between the clamp arm and the
spacer you have to tighten it so the clamp arm actually bends... the
instructions say this is okay, but the clamp pressure to do this is hell of a
lot, Its sufficient just to clamp it up so the heatsink is secure with no
movement.
So maybe some people are over tightening the clamp causing the gpu core to crack
or become damaged in some way.

Mike

Mike
 
W

Wblane

"capillary action", uh right. Have you ever taken physics professor? I never
knew inkjet printers relied on capillary action either.
More likely due to using too much artic silver compound. I have come across
cases where too much A/S was used and it has shot out when hot due to
capillary
action similar to an inkjet printer.


-Bill (remove "botizer" to reply via email)
 
M

Mike

"capillary action", uh right. Have you ever taken physics professor? I never
knew inkjet printers relied on capillary action either.



-Bill (remove "botizer" to reply via email)
No never taken Physics, I was too busy in my youth fighting in the war so you
could have the opportunity to take physics!

Ok... its not capillary action but I'm sure you get the idea. That why artic
silver is not recommended by AMD, check out their site.
 
D

dorkus.erectus

dorkus.erectus said...

Really? Please tell us where you've heard that.

I put one on my 9700 non-pro - allowed me to overclock it to 375MHz,
where the stock speed is 275 MHz. I LOVE my VGA Silencer!

--
DrWho

Abit KX7-333R
XP2700/333
1GB Corsair XMS PC3200 CAS 2.0
ATI 9700non-pro (CPU:375 Mem:303)
Two 80GB WD 7200/8MB in a RAID0


I "heard" from two IT guys at work who happen to be serious OC'ers at home.
But they tell me not to worry since it's an extremely small probability.
I "read" in this NG and other forums.
All I mentioned was that it might be possible. My experience is great so
far.
My 9800 core is happy at 445MHz. (378 stock).

Rick
 
A

AlexN

My Sapphire 9800 pro just died TODAY after putting on the Silencer rev 3.
Used the included normal silicon heat paste.

Visual artifacts on computer Boot up screen, visual artifacts in a 3D game,
really colours funny, and very odd artifacts (none on the desktop or playing
video files).

Then the computer went off, and now the card is completley dead.

If i take it back to the shop, will they find out ive flahsed it to an
XT........hmmm

I didnt tighten the screws overly hard either. Im not sure what to do next.
 
W

Wblane

All I'm saying is it probably takes more than capillary action to get the ink
in a Deskjet onto your paper.

What war did you fight in? The kindergarten kind?
No never taken Physics, I was too busy in my youth fighting in the war so you
could have the opportunity to take physics!

Ok... its not capillary action but I'm sure you get the idea. That why artic
silver is not recommended by AMD, check out their site.


-Bill (remove "botizer" to reply via email)
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Top