MP3 to Midi converter

  • Thread starter Thread starter Paul Woodsford
  • Start date Start date
Anyone know of a freeware mp3 to midi converter that is easy to use.
Click to expand...
This can't really be done, there's a couple of apps that claim it, but at
best they're only monotonic.

It's like reassembling the ingredients from a cake after cooking it, or
rebuilding the sheet music from a record of a symphony.

That's why the midi file is so small, contains only text and is easily
editable.

mike
 
 
Paul said:
Anyone know of a freeware mp3 to midi converter that is easy to use.
Click to expand...
Impossible.

MP3 is audio.
MIDI is a description of tones: a language that controls digital musical
instruments (some of these instruments can occur within software).

A converter would have to be able to extricate one musical line at a
time from a mixture of independent lines. It's been hard enough for
poeple to do this, requiring musical intelligence and the ability to
follow voice leading and similar musical "hints." Can you follow every
single independent line in a Bach organ fugue?

Richard
 
Mike said:
It's like ... rebuilding the sheet music from a record of a symphony.
Click to expand...
It's been hard enough for
Click to expand...
poeple to do this, requiring musical intelligence and the ability to
follow voice leading and similar musical "hints." Can you follow every
single independent line in a Bach organ fugue?

Just to point out: a real professional composer (human being) could do
a pretty good job at either task...it's their job to be that good.

So, if worse came to worse the OP could always pay somebody to
transcribe the music for him. Though I suspect he is interested more
for entertainment/amusement purposes rather than a burning need.

Dave Smey
Music Theory Freeware at http://davesmey.com/programs/programs.htm
 
Paul Woodsford said:
Anyone know of a freeware mp3 to midi converter that is easy to use.
Click to expand...
If you`ve got an mp3 named xxx.mp3, just go and google for xxx.mid..
If the file exists, you`ll get it in mid format. Best I can think of.
bw..OJ
 
Thanks All.
Not being a musician or a computer expert I didn't realise the problems.
Now I do. Anyway thanks.
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Similar Threads

Need Midi To Mp3 Converter 5
Any freeware to convert WAV or MP3 to MIDI files? 5
midi to mp3 or wav. 9
Convert WAV to MP3 4
Convert Midi to mp3? 13
Convert MP3 to Wav and/or MIDI 7
Midi Converter 5
MP3 to MIDI application 4

Back
Top