I should add one slight clarification, Carey is right about RAID requiring
reinstallation under *one* condition, that is, if you do a "software" based
RAID installation. The old WinNT used to support RAID in software, thus
making it OS dependent, but even that form of RAID could be done on an
installed OS. It simply required you to define a similar partition where NT
could replicate its own partition (nothing fancy here). Of course, it only
made sense to do so if you had another HD.
XP (and I presume all future Windows versions) continues the support of RAID
in software, BUT, it is VASTLY different from the old RAID support of WinNT.
This *new* RAID requires the definition of "dynamic disks", which
essentially defines a whole new way of managing your HDs. All your current
partitioning tools, optimizers, etc., would NOT work on these types of
drives! But if you choose to use dynamic drives, then XP would allow you to
define a RAID configuration (but in software, NOT hardware). If you did
choose this route, then YES, it would require a complete reinstallation of
XP because it has XP dependencies built into it!
Personally, you couldn't get me to go anywhere near such a configuration,
far too risky. Besides obsoleting all your current HD tools, XP takes over
the entire HD! You can't use it for anything else but XP because the
dynamic drive concept is XP specific, proprietary. I imagine for some
people this isn't a bother, but for me, no way. It's far, far simpler to
install a little ol' PCI card from Promise and keep all other things the
same. No OS dependencies, all your current HD tools continue to work,
EVERYTHING that's installed on the HDs on the array is mirrored -- data,
other OSs, everything. And if you need to break the mirror, simpy delete
the definition in the card's BIOS. In fact, when I do an OS upgrade, that's
what I do, I break the mirrror, and whalla, I have an INSTANT backup of my
HD! After the upgrade, if all is well, I simply redefine the mirror and
continue. Shwwwwwweet. (if you consider the number of people who BUY
cloning software simply for this purpose only, the card pays for itself!)
Anyway, I just wanted to be complete, I'm sure a lot of people have thought
about RAID, but felt intimidated. Don't be, it's a LOT simpler and straight
forward then most people imagine. I've been using the Promise cards for
years, very reliable and easy to setup. I currently have three machines
using them right now in my office, one using striping (my desktop, for
performance reasons), and two servers (each w/ mirrors).
HTH
Jim