Is USB 1.1 speed a constraint for 100 mbit ethernet?

[Dmitry Kopnichev]

Hello
Is USB 1.1 speed a constraint for 100 mbit Ethernet? Should I change
TRENDnet MEDIAnet USB 1.1 To Fast Ethernet Adapter TU-ET100C to a USB 2.0
Adapter to use full 100 mbit Ethernet?

 

[Bob I]

Please see the difference
http://www.everythingusb.com/usb2/faq.htm

 

[Dmitry Kopnichev]

The http://www.everythingusb.com/usb2/faq.htm says nothing about Ethernet.

 

[Bob I]

You asked about "constraints" for 100 mbit data connection. The ethernet
part is not relavent.

 

[Arkady Frenkel]

Unless you'll find the server you can download from with a speed more that
12 Mb/sec you can use USB 1 ( I never saw that up to now )
Arkady

 

[Dmitry Kopnichev]

What if from several servers, several threads?

Unless you'll find the server you can download from with a speed more that
12 Mb/sec you can use USB 1 ( I never saw that up to now )
Arkady

 

[Gary Tsang]

Only you can answer that (as we don't know what servers you are using).

 

[Rob Stow]

One thing to keep in mind is that with USB devices, the CPU does
all the work in managing the traffic.

I have seen CPU usage numbers for USB ethernet run steadily at
about 35% with peaks at 60% on a 2.4 GHz P4 - even though the
computer owner's broadband connection was only 2 Mbps.

He was very frequently getting slow network speeds when the CPU
was too busy to give the USB ethernet the attention it needed.
Conversely, if the CPU was giving too many cpu cycles to the USB
ethernet, then performance in other apps really suffered and the
system was unresponsive to user input.

Since this guy liked to play multi-player games over the www,
having the network connection eat up so much of his CPU's
frequently meant stuttering performance in the games.
Conversely, if he gave the game a higher priority, then not
enough CPU cycles were left for USB ethernet.

Installing a real NIC into a PCI slot solved that user's
problems. A $30 NIC did far more for his gaming performance than
his $400 video card upgrade. CPU usage by the PCI NIC seldom
hits 4%.

 

[Gary Tsang]

Yeah, that's definitely another consideration.

Unless the OP is using a laptop, he really should just get an actual network
card, rather than trying to pipe it through USB. While USB may seem more
convenient, it really isn't as good as using an actual ethernet card.

 

[Dmitry Kopnichev]

I have not seen high CPU usage by USB NIC yet. I bought USB NIC to
disconnect it quick.