F
Fran Tirimo
I am developing a small website using ASP scripts to format data retrieved
from an Access database. It will run on a Windows 2003 server supporting
FrontPage extensions 2002 hosted by the company 1&1 with only limited server
configuration via a web based control panel.
My query relates to the ASP security model and how it relates to FrontPage
options for setting file access on a database file. If you know of any
online documentation covering the following issues I would be grateful for
links to it.
For various reasons (session logging, synchronising data with a master
database etc) I need to be able to write data to the database file.
Essentially the problem is this: how do I make this possible without giving
public access to the database file?
The 1&1 control panel allows me to set Read/Write/Execute/Delete permissions
for "IUSR" (I assume to mean annoymous unauthenticated users) and "NETWORK"
users (I am not sure what this refers to yet).
So far the only way I have managed to write to the database file from an ASP
script is by using the control panel to set the following IUSR permissions
on the database file:
Read = true (cannot alter this)
Write = true
Execute = true
Delete = false
I understand that when as ASP script executes, it takes on a "security
context" corresponding to the user requesting the page. In my case, when an
annonymous user makes a request that needs to be logged to the database for
example, the script that performs the logging has annonymous user
privelages. Therefore for the write to the database to be successful, IUSR
write permissions must be allowed.
Of course, these permission settings have some undesireable side effects:
1 - With "Read = true" on the database file for annonymous users means
that anyone can download the database file.
2 - With "Write = true" annonymous users could in theory directly alter
the database file eg using telnet or some similar method.
I am not sure if this this second point is true...
- What exactly do annonymous write permissions on a file/directory allow
to occur?
- I am not yet sure if the server is set up to ONLY accept HTTP GET and
POST commands from annonymous users but have contacted the hosting company
about this.
I may have found a solution to the above issues. As I am using FrontPage to
publish the site I may be able to take advantage of FP's file permission
settings by disallowing browsing by annonymous users for the directory
containg the database file.
What I need to know is whether my suggested solution to the problem really
prevents anonymous users from downloading/modifying my database file and how
would I test this?
I assume that I still have to allow IUSR read/write access to the database
file, given the ASP security issues mentioned above. (Are FP permissions
considered by the web server instead of or in conjunction with Windows file
permissions when deciding if access to a resource is to be allowed?)
To check my understanding of FP folder permissions...
- Allow files to be browsed - does this prevent downloading of files in
the folder as well as preventing folder contents from being viewed from ANY
HTTP client?
- Allow scripts to be run - does this refer to annonymous users being
allowed to view pages generated by scripts within the folder? Or does it
refer to scripts in other folders access files/data in the said folder?
- Allow prrograms to be run - this is probably not relevant to me and I
should probably disallow this option.
Also, I have read that you can create a "hidden" folder in FP just by giving
it a name beginning with an underscore. Would such a folder allow a script
to access/write to a dataqbase file? My tests seem to show that the _private
directory created by default in new FP webs does NOT allow scripts to write
to files.
Finally, is there any way within an ASP script to assume a more privileged
security context? For example, would using Sever.Execute to call another
script containg the code to modify the database use a more privileged
security context?
Thanks for your help
Francesco Tirimo
(e-mail address removed)
from an Access database. It will run on a Windows 2003 server supporting
FrontPage extensions 2002 hosted by the company 1&1 with only limited server
configuration via a web based control panel.
My query relates to the ASP security model and how it relates to FrontPage
options for setting file access on a database file. If you know of any
online documentation covering the following issues I would be grateful for
links to it.
For various reasons (session logging, synchronising data with a master
database etc) I need to be able to write data to the database file.
Essentially the problem is this: how do I make this possible without giving
public access to the database file?
The 1&1 control panel allows me to set Read/Write/Execute/Delete permissions
for "IUSR" (I assume to mean annoymous unauthenticated users) and "NETWORK"
users (I am not sure what this refers to yet).
So far the only way I have managed to write to the database file from an ASP
script is by using the control panel to set the following IUSR permissions
on the database file:
Read = true (cannot alter this)
Write = true
Execute = true
Delete = false
I understand that when as ASP script executes, it takes on a "security
context" corresponding to the user requesting the page. In my case, when an
annonymous user makes a request that needs to be logged to the database for
example, the script that performs the logging has annonymous user
privelages. Therefore for the write to the database to be successful, IUSR
write permissions must be allowed.
Of course, these permission settings have some undesireable side effects:
1 - With "Read = true" on the database file for annonymous users means
that anyone can download the database file.
2 - With "Write = true" annonymous users could in theory directly alter
the database file eg using telnet or some similar method.
I am not sure if this this second point is true...
- What exactly do annonymous write permissions on a file/directory allow
to occur?
- I am not yet sure if the server is set up to ONLY accept HTTP GET and
POST commands from annonymous users but have contacted the hosting company
about this.
I may have found a solution to the above issues. As I am using FrontPage to
publish the site I may be able to take advantage of FP's file permission
settings by disallowing browsing by annonymous users for the directory
containg the database file.
What I need to know is whether my suggested solution to the problem really
prevents anonymous users from downloading/modifying my database file and how
would I test this?
I assume that I still have to allow IUSR read/write access to the database
file, given the ASP security issues mentioned above. (Are FP permissions
considered by the web server instead of or in conjunction with Windows file
permissions when deciding if access to a resource is to be allowed?)
To check my understanding of FP folder permissions...
- Allow files to be browsed - does this prevent downloading of files in
the folder as well as preventing folder contents from being viewed from ANY
HTTP client?
- Allow scripts to be run - does this refer to annonymous users being
allowed to view pages generated by scripts within the folder? Or does it
refer to scripts in other folders access files/data in the said folder?
- Allow prrograms to be run - this is probably not relevant to me and I
should probably disallow this option.
Also, I have read that you can create a "hidden" folder in FP just by giving
it a name beginning with an underscore. Would such a folder allow a script
to access/write to a dataqbase file? My tests seem to show that the _private
directory created by default in new FP webs does NOT allow scripts to write
to files.
Finally, is there any way within an ASP script to assume a more privileged
security context? For example, would using Sever.Execute to call another
script containg the code to modify the database use a more privileged
security context?
Thanks for your help
Francesco Tirimo
(e-mail address removed)