DNS / MX problem

J

Jeremy

Hello,

I have a problem with DNS server on Windows 2000 Server.

I don't receive e-mails on the correct server.
Example with "very-long-domain.com":
; Zone Records
@ A 66.192.XXX.XXX
@ MX 10 mail.very-long-domain.com.
ftp CNAME very-long-domain.com.
mail A 212.182.XXX.XXX
www CNAME very-long-domain.com.

E-mails are received by 66.192.XXX.XXX whereas they should be received by
212.182.XXX.XXX. Do you know how is it possible?? I specify that when I go
to http://mail.very-long-domain.com, I got an answer from the right server
(I mean the Web is OK, my problem is just with the e-mail).

Thanks in advance for your help !

Jeremy
 
D

Deji Akomolafe

nslookup
server ns1.cisco.com
set q=mx
very-long-domain.com

Who is listed there? I bet it's 66.192.XXX.XXX and not 212.182.XXX.XXX

Don't be shy about posting your real domain name, unless there is an
internal rule prohibiting that. It helps people help you better, IMO.

--
Sincerely,

Dèjì Akómöláfé, MCSE MCSA MCP+I
www.akomolafe.com
www.iyaburo.com
Do you now realize that Today is the Tomorrow you were worried about
Yesterday? -anon
 
J

Jeremy

Thanks for your answer.
I cannot post the real domain name, sorry.

nslookup
server ns1.cisco.com
set q=mx
very-long-domain.com

result :
Non-authoritative answer:
very-long-domain.com MX preference=10, mail
exchanger=mail.very-long-domain.com
Authoritative answer can be found from:
....ns1...
....ns2...
mail.very-long-domain.com A internet (IPv4) address=212.182.XXX.XXX

So I really do not understand why e-mails don't go to the right server
(212.182.XXX.XXX)...
When I send an e-mail to (e-mail address removed), I get a
mailer-deamon message from the other server (66.192.XXX.XXX) telling me that
he doesn't know this domain (which is obviously normal).

Jeremy
 
A

Ace Fekay [MVP]

In
Jeremy said:
Thanks for your answer.
I cannot post the real domain name, sorry.

nslookup
server ns1.cisco.com
set q=mx
very-long-domain.com

result :
Non-authoritative answer:
very-long-domain.com MX preference=10, mail
exchanger=mail.very-long-domain.com
Authoritative answer can be found from:
...ns1...
...ns2...
mail.very-long-domain.com A internet (IPv4)
address=212.182.XXX.XXX

So I really do not understand why e-mails don't go to the right server
(212.182.XXX.XXX)...
When I send an e-mail to (e-mail address removed), I get a
mailer-deamon message from the other server (66.192.XXX.XXX) telling
me that he doesn't know this domain (which is obviously normal).

Jeremy

Can you try the nslookup from a machine outside of your network?

You can also check your domain records at:
dnsstuff.com
dnsreport.com

Unless since you are internal, and you have a split-horizon zone and you
manually created the record with the 66. address.


--
Regards,
Ace

Please direct all replies to the newsgroup so all can benefit.
This posting is provided "AS IS" with no warranties.

Ace Fekay, MCSE 2000, MCSE+I, MCSA, MCT, MVP
Microsoft Windows MVP - Active Directory
 
J

Jeremy

"Ace Fekay [MVP]"
In

Can you try the nslookup from a machine outside of your network?

You can also check your domain records at:
dnsstuff.com
dnsreport.com

Unless since you are internal, and you have a split-horizon zone and you
manually created the record with the 66. address.

OK, I give you the exact domain name :
harvestbirdhouse.com

You can try to send an e-mail to (e-mail address removed), you'll see that
is not the correct server who answers...
Thanks again :)

Jeremy (and sorry for the bad english)
 
K

Kevin D. Goodknecht [MVP]

In Jeremy <[email protected]> posted a question
Then Kevin replied below:
: "Ace Fekay [MVP]"
: <PleaseSubstituteMyActualFirstName&[email protected]> a écrit
: dans le message de news: (e-mail address removed)...
:: In :: Jeremy <[email protected]> posted their thoughts, then I offered mine
::: Thanks for your answer.
::: I cannot post the real domain name, sorry.
:::
::: nslookup
::: server ns1.cisco.com
::: set q=mx
::: very-long-domain.com
:::
::: result :
::: Non-authoritative answer:
::: very-long-domain.com MX preference=10, mail
::: exchanger=mail.very-long-domain.com
::: Authoritative answer can be found from:
::: ...ns1...
::: ...ns2...
::: mail.very-long-domain.com A internet (IPv4)
::: address=212.182.XXX.XXX
:::
::: So I really do not understand why e-mails don't go to the right
::: server (212.182.XXX.XXX)...
::: When I send an e-mail to (e-mail address removed), I get a
::: mailer-deamon message from the other server (66.192.XXX.XXX) telling
::: me that he doesn't know this domain (which is obviously normal).
:::
::: Jeremy
:::
::: "Deji Akomolafe" <[email protected]> a écrit dans le message de
::: news: (e-mail address removed)...
:::: nslookup
:::: server ns1.cisco.com
:::: set q=mx
:::: very-long-domain.com
::::
:::: Who is listed there? I bet it's 66.192.XXX.XXX and not
:::: 212.182.XXX.XXX
::::
:::: Don't be shy about posting your real domain name, unless there is
:::: an internal rule prohibiting that. It helps people help you
:::: better, IMO.
::::
:::: --
:::: Sincerely,
::::
:::: Dèjì Akómöláfé, MCSE MCSA MCP+I
:::: www.akomolafe.com
:::: www.iyaburo.com
:::: Do you now realize that Today is the Tomorrow you were worried
:::: about Yesterday? -anon
:::: ::::: Hello,
:::::
::::: I have a problem with DNS server on Windows 2000 Server.
:::::
::::: I don't receive e-mails on the correct server.
::::: Example with "very-long-domain.com":
::::: ; Zone Records
::::: @ A 66.192.XXX.XXX
::::: @ MX 10 mail.very-long-domain.com.
::::: ftp CNAME very-long-domain.com.
::::: mail A 212.182.XXX.XXX
::::: www CNAME very-long-domain.com.
:::::
::::: E-mails are received by 66.192.XXX.XXX whereas they should be
::::: received by 212.182.XXX.XXX. Do you know how is it possible?? I
::::: specify that when I go to http://mail.very-long-domain.com, I got
::::: an answer from the right server (I mean the Web is OK, my problem
::::: is just with the e-mail).
:::::
::::: Thanks in advance for your help !
:::::
::::: Jeremy
::
:: Can you try the nslookup from a machine outside of your network?
::
:: You can also check your domain records at:
:: dnsstuff.com
:: dnsreport.com
::
:: Unless since you are internal, and you have a split-horizon zone and
:: you manually created the record with the 66. address.
:
: OK, I give you the exact domain name :
: harvestbirdhouse.com
:
: You can try to send an e-mail to (e-mail address removed), you'll
: see that is not the correct server who answers...
: Thanks again :)
:
: Jeremy (and sorry for the bad english)
Getting MX record for harvestbirdhouse.com... Got it!

Host Preference IP(s) [Country]
mail.harvestbirdhouse.com. 10 213.186.46.49 [FR]


This is where the public record says to send mail.
Take a look at this: http://www.dnsreport.com/tools/dnsreport.ch?domain=harvestbirdhouse.com

--
Best regards,
Kevin D4 Dad Goodknecht Sr. [MVP]
Hope This Helps
============================
--
When responding to posts, please "Reply to Group" via your
newsreader so that others may learn and benefit from your issue.
To respond directly to me remove the nospam. from my email.
==========================================
http://www.lonestaramerica.com/
==========================================
Use Outlook Express?... Get OE_Quotefix:
It will strip signature out and more
http://home.in.tum.de/~jain/software/oe-quotefix/
==========================================
Keep a back up of your OE settings and folders with
OEBackup:
http://www.oehelp.com/OEBackup/Default.aspx
==========================================
 
J

Jeremy

"Kevin D. Goodknecht [MVP]" <[email protected]> a écrit dans le message
de #[email protected]...
In Jeremy <[email protected]> posted a question
Then Kevin replied below:
: "Ace Fekay [MVP]"
: <PleaseSubstituteMyActualFirstName&[email protected]> a écrit
: dans le message de news: (e-mail address removed)...
:: In :: Jeremy <[email protected]> posted their thoughts, then I offered mine
::: Thanks for your answer.
::: I cannot post the real domain name, sorry.
:::
::: nslookup
::: server ns1.cisco.com
::: set q=mx
::: very-long-domain.com
:::
::: result :
::: Non-authoritative answer:
::: very-long-domain.com MX preference=10, mail
::: exchanger=mail.very-long-domain.com
::: Authoritative answer can be found from:
::: ...ns1...
::: ...ns2...
::: mail.very-long-domain.com A internet (IPv4)
::: address=212.182.XXX.XXX
:::
::: So I really do not understand why e-mails don't go to the right
::: server (212.182.XXX.XXX)...
::: When I send an e-mail to (e-mail address removed), I get a
::: mailer-deamon message from the other server (66.192.XXX.XXX) telling
::: me that he doesn't know this domain (which is obviously normal).
:::
::: Jeremy
:::
::: "Deji Akomolafe" <[email protected]> a écrit dans le message de
::: news: (e-mail address removed)...
:::: nslookup
:::: server ns1.cisco.com
:::: set q=mx
:::: very-long-domain.com
::::
:::: Who is listed there? I bet it's 66.192.XXX.XXX and not
:::: 212.182.XXX.XXX
::::
:::: Don't be shy about posting your real domain name, unless there is
:::: an internal rule prohibiting that. It helps people help you
:::: better, IMO.
::::
:::: --
:::: Sincerely,
::::
:::: Dèjì Akómöláfé, MCSE MCSA MCP+I
:::: www.akomolafe.com
:::: www.iyaburo.com
:::: Do you now realize that Today is the Tomorrow you were worried
:::: about Yesterday? -anon
:::: ::::: Hello,
:::::
::::: I have a problem with DNS server on Windows 2000 Server.
:::::
::::: I don't receive e-mails on the correct server.
::::: Example with "very-long-domain.com":
::::: ; Zone Records
::::: @ A 66.192.XXX.XXX
::::: @ MX 10 mail.very-long-domain.com.
::::: ftp CNAME very-long-domain.com.
::::: mail A 212.182.XXX.XXX
::::: www CNAME very-long-domain.com.
:::::
::::: E-mails are received by 66.192.XXX.XXX whereas they should be
::::: received by 212.182.XXX.XXX. Do you know how is it possible?? I
::::: specify that when I go to http://mail.very-long-domain.com, I got
::::: an answer from the right server (I mean the Web is OK, my problem
::::: is just with the e-mail).
:::::
::::: Thanks in advance for your help !
:::::
::::: Jeremy
::
:: Can you try the nslookup from a machine outside of your network?
::
:: You can also check your domain records at:
:: dnsstuff.com
:: dnsreport.com
::
:: Unless since you are internal, and you have a split-horizon zone and
:: you manually created the record with the 66. address.
:
: OK, I give you the exact domain name :
: harvestbirdhouse.com
:
: You can try to send an e-mail to (e-mail address removed), you'll
: see that is not the correct server who answers...
: Thanks again :)
:
: Jeremy (and sorry for the bad english)
Getting MX record for harvestbirdhouse.com... Got it!

Host Preference IP(s) [Country]
mail.harvestbirdhouse.com. 10 213.186.46.49 [FR]


This is where the public record says to send mail.
Take a look at this:
http://www.dnsreport.com/tools/dnsreport.ch?domain=harvestbirdhouse.com

Yes, thank you.
But if you send an e-mail to (e-mail address removed), you'll have an
answer from 213.186.39.52 whereas it should be 213.186.46.49.
Do you understand ?
Jeremy.
 
J

Jonathan de Boyne Pollard

J> OK, I give you the exact domain name :
J> harvestbirdhouse.com

There is no 66.192.*.* IP address involved here. However, IP address for SMTP
Relay service for mailboxes in "harvestbirdhouse.com." is different to the IP
address for other services:

[C:\]dnsgetmx harvestbirdhouse.com.
213.186.46.49
[C:\]dnsgeta harvestbirdhouse.com.
213.186.39.52
[C:\]
 
J

Jonathan de Boyne Pollard

J> But if you send an e-mail to (e-mail address removed), you'll
J> have an answer from 213.186.39.52 whereas it should be 213.186.46.49.

If I were to send mail to that mailbox, it would be sent to
the SMTP Relay server listening on 213.186.46.49.

[C:\]dnsgetmx harvestbirdhouse.com.
213.186.46.49
[C:\]

Where any replies to my message come from is an entirely different
matter that is unrelated to either DNS service or SMTP Relay service.
 
J

Jeremy

OK I found the solution !
In fact I was using 213.186.39.52 as SMTP, i.e. the same machine where the
Web is hosted. So this SMTP was searching in his local mail domains and
found "harvestbirdhouse.com" in them...
So I deleted the mail domain "harvestbirdhouse.com" on 213.186.39.52, and it
works!

Thanks again for you help.

Sincerely,
Jeremy
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Top