Can you reproduce Excel unexpectedly closing?

[Jerry W. Lewis]

Can anyone else reproduce this problem? Is there a known solution other than
"don't do that"?

If I copy a region (1 or more cells) in Excel and then open another Office
product (I tested Word, Power Point, and Access) while the copy border is
still blinking, then Excel closes without warning (and without closing Excel
Help if it is open). When I reopen Excel, there will only be an attempt to
recover if the document was edited for a long enough period of time for an
autosave to occur.

This appears to be the reproducible conditions for
http://groups.google.com/group/microsoft.public.excel.misc/browse_thread/thread/dc5b1fb7307342d8
which generated no traffic, and may also explain
http://groups.google.com/group/microsoft.public.excel.misc/browse_thread/thread/d2134c202b87c1a1

My best guess (assuming that it is reproducible on other machines) is that
it has something to do with office products initializing the Office Clipboard
when they start. Does it also plague other versions of Office?

I have Office 2003 SP2 and Win XP Pro SP2 on an HP T5600 Centrino Duo laptop.

Jerry


P.S. Another report of Excel closing unexpectedly
http://groups.google.com/group/microsoft.public.excel.misc/browse_thread/thread/4b048c625ef1dff5
may be due to a different mechanism

 

[fisher]

I have experienced two occasions over the last week when Excel 2007 has
closed unexpectedly. On one occasion I had three workbooks open and then
worked in another application for awhile. When I looked for my Excel tab at
the bottom of the screen it was gone. I re-opened Excel and it offered me
the auto-saved versions of my workbooks, which still required me to repeat
some of my work.

Today I had only one workbook open. I had inserted one Microsoft Equation
Editor equation into a spreadsheet and began to insert another when Excel
just disappeared. I re-opened it and opened the auto-saved version of my
spreadsheet, again requiring me to redo some work.

This is annoying and time consuming. I would appreciate any further
information on this problem. I don't want to pay Microsoft $49 to let them
know about this problem.

Fisher

 

[Alan]

I have experienced two occasions over the last week when Excel 2007 has
closed unexpectedly.  On one occasion I had three workbooks open and then
worked in another application for awhile.  When I looked for my Excel tab at
the bottom of the screen it was gone.  I re-opened Excel and it offered me
the auto-saved versions of my workbooks, which still required me to repeat
some of my work.

Today I had only one workbook open.  I had inserted one Microsoft Equation
Editor equation into a spreadsheet and began to insert another when Excel
just disappeared.  I re-opened it and opened the auto-saved version of my
spreadsheet, again requiring me to redo some work.

This is annoying and time consuming.  I would appreciate any further
information on this problem.  I don't want to pay Microsoft $49 to let them
know about this problem.

Fisher









- Show quoted text -

Hi,

I think your excel files are corrupt. You can try a popular Excel file
recovery tool called Advanced Excel Repair to repair your Excel file.
It is a powerful tool to repair corrupt or damaged Excel files.

Detailed information about Advanced Excel Repair can be found at
http://www.datanumen.com/aer/

And you can also download a free demo version at http://www.datanumen.com/aer/aer.exe

Alan