Backing up CD's is it legal?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Guest
  • Start date Start date
G

Guest

Before I do anything I was wondering if anyone can tell me if it is ok to make a backup copy of my windows 2000 pro cd?

The reason im asking is the CD has started to crack in the center from pulling it out of the case and I am afraid of it breaking or shattering in my cdrom. I was wondering if I have the original CD and License if it was legal for me to make a backup copy to have incase I need to reinstall again?

Thanks
 
Pete said:
Before I do anything I was wondering if anyone can tell me if it is ok to make a backup copy of my windows 2000 pro cd?

The reason im asking is the CD has started to crack in the center from pulling it out of the case and I am afraid of it breaking
or shattering in my cdrom. I was wondering if I have the original CD and License if it was legal for me to make a backup copy to
have incase I need to reinstall again?

Absolutely legal, at least in the U.S.

Rick
 
Today its legal ... tomorrow it might not be.

You'd better make several backups today, just to be sure.

The DMCA has trampled all over your rights as a consumer and its only gonna
get worse. After all, thats what bought-and-paid-for congress critters are
all about.


Pete said:
Before I do anything I was wondering if anyone can tell me if it is ok to
make a backup copy of my windows 2000 pro cd?
The reason im asking is the CD has started to crack in the center from
pulling it out of the case and I am afraid of it breaking or shattering in
my cdrom. I was wondering if I have the original CD and License if it was
legal for me to make a backup copy to have incase I need to reinstall again?
 
Technically, Making more than one copy of an operating system plus
their software violates dmca and the eula. Also, you can violate the
eula by making two nortons ghost backup. It say you can make only
one backup. However, I think you should be able to make as many
backup as you want.




Brian
 
I would make a backup copy and also write to Microsoft and
see if they can replace the CD for you - write first
before sending it in, you never know if it'll come back to
you otherwise.

If it's a legit version of their software, I don't see why
they wouldn't accept it.
-----Original Message-----
Before I do anything I was wondering if anyone can tell
me if it is ok to make a backup copy of my windows 2000
pro cd?
The reason im asking is the CD has started to crack in
the center from pulling it out of the case and I am afraid
of it breaking or shattering in my cdrom. I was wondering
if I have the original CD and License if it was legal for
me to make a backup copy to have incase I need to
reinstall again?
 
I'd re-read the DMCA. If it was true then it's illegal for me to have
rotating backup tapes of my servers.

Steve
 
Brian said:
Technically, Making more than one copy of an operating system plus
their software violates dmca and the eula. Also, you can violate the
eula by making two nortons ghost backup. It say you can make only
one backup. However, I think you should be able to make as many
backup as you want.

Right after NT4 for Alpha came out, I was one of two IT guys
at a small branch office. The local servers at the branches
were Alpha-based boxes made by Digital and running Unix.

The decision came down from the top to migrate all of the
branch office Alphas to NT4. I soon ran into tape backup
issues and dealt with Digital's techies - who at some point
talked to MicroSoft. I subsequently got a letter from MicroSoft
demanding licensing fees for every copy of NT that was on
the tapes. I passed that on to my superiors at the
main office for them to deal with and the decision immediately
came down - corporate wide - to halt the transition to NT4
and to go back to Unix where systems had already been converted.

A few months later I got a phone call from MicroSoft asking why
I hadn't replied to their letter. I explained that because of that
letter we had gone back to Unix and destroyed all backup tapes that
had NT on them. MicroSoft gave it the old college try to get that
decision reversed, but it was too late - the reversion to Unix was
already completed and the IT director was too mad to give NT4 another
try.

And you can bet your buns that I caught hell for saying anything
at all to that phone call from MicroSoft instead of passing them
on for HQ to deal with. :-D
 
Make enough laws and eventually everyone becomes a criminal.

The DMCA has failed more legal challenges than it's passed, and
will eventually be repealed. It's horrendously written, ridiculously
broad and utterly unenforceable. Even librarians and researchers
are being repressed by this law.

Use the software you buy however you want to use it. Just don't
resell it or give it away, and let the silly corporate prostitutes in
D.C. haggle over what's legal. Simple, no?

Rick
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Back
Top