Western Digital Warranty Issues

J

J.Clarke

I have a 120GB SE Model that was manufactured April 2002 and it failed
on me in September of 2002. I haven't been able to convince western
digital to take it back and give me a replacement under warranty. They
rejected it cause of the serial # which they claim indicates it is a
Dell drive but i see no markings for it being one.

Western Digital does not put "Dell" labels on drives they sell to Dell.
Nonetheless they do keep a record of which drives were sold under which
contract.
I have no receipt
anymore for the drive and since I got it in Summer 2002 there is no
returning it to the store anymore. The model is WD1200JB-75CRA0 which
I believe to be OEM rather than Retail but am not positive. I've never
heard of a large HD like this which has "no warranty" from Western
Digital and I have been buying them for years now. This same model
drive at the store would include a 3 yr warranty. Anyone have any
suggestions besides chucking it into the garbage? I paid nearly $200
for it last year and would rather not throw it away, if there is any
way I can get it replaced. :-( Thanks for any advisement and help.

If it came in a Dell call Dell. If it didn't come in a Dell you're
screwed.

All drive manufacturers sell drives to computer manufacturers under
contracts that specify that the drive is warranteed to the computer
manufacturer and the computer manufacturer is responsible for providing
warranty support to their customer. The reason they do this is that by
not having to include the cost of end-user support in the price of the
drive they can sell the drives to the computer manufacturers at a
discount, which the computer manufacturers want.

If, however, you get one of those drives that was surplused or removed
for upgrade or got into the retail channel in some other way, the only
warranty you have is whatever was provided by the store you bought it
from.

Now, before some yahoo says "I got an OEM drive and it had a warranty",
the drive manufacturers also sell "brown box" OEM drives intended to be
sold by wholesalers to small volume manufacturers and consultants who
don't do enough volume to make negotiating a contract directly with the
manufacturer worthwhile. Officially those are warranteed to the
manufacturer, but if you buy one and install it you're effectively the
manufacturer so it's warranteed to you--in any case the manufacturers
don't have any way to track this after the drives go to the wholesalers
so they're functionally discounted retail drives without the pretty box
or whatever accessories are normally included.

It appears based on what you said that the drive you have is one that
was sold to Dell under the kind of contract that makes Dell responsibly
for providing support to the end user, so unless you can get support
from Dell you pretty much don't have a warranty.

Some state laws override such contracts, if you feel strongly about this
it might be worthwhile to look up the applicable statutes and see what
they say and if they seem to support the notion that you have a warranty
regardless of the contract you might talk to your state's department of
consumer affairs or whatever they call it where you live. But don't
expect anything to happen soon if you do that--it takes them time to
build a case and they won't generally act on a single complaint unless
the offense creates a danger to life or risk of major property damage or
is sufficiently egregious to draw media or political attention.
 
S

Someone

I have a 120GB SE Model that was manufactured April 2002 and it failed on me
in September of 2002. I haven't been able to convince western digital to
take it back and give me a replacement under warranty. They rejected it
cause of the serial # which they claim indicates it is a Dell drive but i
see no markings for it being one. I have no receipt anymore for the drive
and since I got it in Summer 2002 there is no returning it to the store
anymore. The model is WD1200JB-75CRA0 which I believe to be OEM rather than
Retail but am not positive. I've never heard of a large HD like this which
has "no warranty" from Western Digital and I have been buying them for years
now. This same model drive at the store would include a 3 yr warranty.
Anyone have any suggestions besides chucking it into the garbage? I paid
nearly $200 for it last year and would rather not throw it away, if there is
any way I can get it replaced. :-( Thanks for any advisement and help.



Dan
 
P

Peter Piper

I have a 120GB SE Model that was manufactured April 2002 and it failed on me
in September of 2002. I haven't been able to convince western digital to
take it back and give me a replacement under warranty. They rejected it
cause of the serial # which they claim indicates it is a Dell drive but i
see no markings for it being one. I have no receipt anymore for the drive
and since I got it in Summer 2002 there is no returning it to the store
anymore. The model is WD1200JB-75CRA0 which I believe to be OEM rather than
Retail but am not positive. I've never heard of a large HD like this which
has "no warranty" from Western Digital and I have been buying them for years
now. This same model drive at the store would include a 3 yr warranty.
Anyone have any suggestions besides chucking it into the garbage? I paid
nearly $200 for it last year and would rather not throw it away, if there is
any way I can get it replaced. :-( Thanks for any advisement and help.
Just curious... Did you buy this drive from a major chain like Best Buy,
Circuit City, CompUSA, Fryes, etc? If so I would think the store manager
would be concerned about a drive they sold being OEM Dell.

A small store may have screwed you. Have you talked to your place of
purchase yet? Maybe they did not know it was OEM either.

WD is not going to help. Looks like it goes in the trash from my seat
unless the place of purchase cares.

Peter
 
S

Scott Davis

Here is my post of 110803,

Doesn't help you much but I think WD is having a run of bad drives.

Hi all,

I am a custom system builder specializing in custom systems for games for
extended family and our friends. (used to have own business but couldn't
make money - do it for fun now).

I have exclusively used Western Digital Special Edition Drives for their
performance and 3 year warranty.

However, I have experienced numerous drive failures of late. Some are with
the power up of brand new hard drives and require RMA. Western Digital
never gives me a problem and readily RMA's the drives both old and "brand
New".

Note: that the new SE drives from western digital are lighter and appear to
be the same type of drive as their economy series with 1 year warranty and
only 2 MB cache. They feel cheap and I just had a brand new drive sound the
click of death upon first power up!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Anyone had similar problems??? Please advise and let the world know what
must be happening to others out there.

Sincerely,
Scott Davis
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Top