On Fri, 23 Mar 2007 16:56:17 -0700, "Jack Splat =\(8\)"
Well then Jimmy I guess the people at Microsoft don't know what they are
talking about. I asked why they added UAC the way they did. And my post was
the jist of why they added it they way the did.
The reasons why MS add a feature are interesting, but may turn out to
be of limited relevance.
As an MS Office user at the turn of the century, 99% of "document"
macros encountered would be malware. Does it matter that MS intended
this to be a Useful Feature [TM]? Nope. Same thing goes with the
"useful feature" of scripts automatically running in unsolicited email
"message text", as was designed into OE4 and OE5, and was STILL left
On by duhfault in post-Kak WinME.
So yes, I'm interested in why MS does things, but I don't stop
thinking after I've read their stuff.
MS 2007 isn't MS 2000, in that they aren't as ignorant of adverse
implications as they were in those Polyanna days. You may well find
the reverse is true where UAC is concerned; maybe it was intended as a
temporary compatibility smooth-over from XP to Vista application
design, but the main value may be as a malware trip-wire.
It's also not an entirely unexpected phenomenon.
Firstly, elevation prompts are common enough in MacOS and Linux that
even a toe-in-the-water dabbler such as myself hasn't had a day on
these OSs without encountering them at least once.
Secondly, there's a trend in safety add-ons to generalize the firewall
egress monitoring "alert and learn" model to internal events. PrevX
and All-Seeing-Eye are two examples of this that work much as UAC
does; they don't attempt to understand why something is being
attempted, they just step in and give you a chance to Just Say No.
Finally, UAC has already demonstrated its value to me. Yes, I'm
peeved about the 200+ times I've had to nod through "yes, I really
want to rename this Start Menu item" alerts, but I was happy to see an
unexpected UAC alert pop up when looking for drivers for an old
scanner. As one of the "found" pages started to dribble down the
screen, UAC popped up asking whether it was OK to... ("NO")
-------------------- ----- ---- --- -- - - - -
Tip Of The Day:
To disable the 'Tip of the Day' feature...