I must say, I found this to be a whole grey area myself. My initial reaction was that a crack would be illegal, but after searching around I reached the conclusion if you owned the game, it was generally considered OK.
However, one cannot overlook the fact that certain game disks can be copied and the only way they'll run is with one of these cracks.
Both the sites mentioned in this thread have been there several years and have not been threatened with legal action (AFAIK) and have not been closed down. Unlike certain P2P sites and some that stored archives of audio CD sleeves.
I'm no lawyer, but my guess is that the software companies tolerate the sites. As for the exact legal position, I have not a clue, but I have read articles in magazines such as PC Zone saying it is actually legal in the UK to make backup copies of games you've legitimately purchased. But that's not really the issue here.
I guess the answer could be found in the small print of those agreements you agree to when you load the game, but I don't think I've ever read a one. And anyway, I think some of the things software publishers stipulate in those agreements aren't strictly legal themsleves.
I have carried links to both sites mentioned in this thread at other Forums for several years now without a problem. I use cracks myself, purely for the convenience of not having to load CD's for each game I play, as I have a lot of games loaded. I have purchased all the games I play, I might add.
Whether we're on dodgy ground or not discussing game cracks in this Forum, I'm not really sure, but as long as discussions don't err to warez and the like, I'd personally consider it safe.
Having said that, to be on the safe side, I'd have to say it would be wise for Ian to lock this thread and discourage/delete/ban any mention of it ever again. I mean, that would be really taking things to extremes, imo, but it would be the safest action to take.
Forums that dealt a lot with illegal activities have been closed. If cracks are illegal, or more importantly, if cracks irritate software publishers, we should be careful.
So, to sum up, I really don't know. Your decision, Ian
