Thee Chicago Wolf added these comments in the current discussion
du jour ...
It is all contingent upon what a user has installed on his /
her system that oft determines how well a service pack or
patch is received into the established environment. Microsoft
cannot possibly account for every single application that is
out there and be able to test against them. That just isn't
possible. It isn't rational to avoid service pack 3 since the
vast majority of updates since SP2 are already built in. If
you system is stable now, it'll likely be stable with SP3. I
am running build 3311 on my production work laptop with zero
issues. It was stable before I installed SP3 and is stable
currently.
I agree with your basic thesis except for SP3.
At some point - I thought it would be Vista - MS needs to cut the
apron strings to the old DOS days including its 8.3 file name
restriction, make Windows a modern GUI O/S, get rid of the bloat
that comes from at least trying to accomodate every piece of
legacy SW and HW ever invented, and maybe, just maybe, improve
its reliability. To do that, of course, they would need to
obsolete all of its earlier customers, which they are loathe to
do. Still, if they don't do it someday on all-NEW versions, they
will never attain the stability that the loyal Mac and Linux
people claim.
As to whether any SP is or is not stable depends highly on system
configs and what HW, SW, video card, and other things you have.
e.g., you're running just fine with a pre-release SP3 but I may
have a major blowdown. But, please don't insult everyone by
suggesting they aren't rational if they don't install SP3;
instead, re-read your own reply - the part about it being
impossible for MS to account for everything and ask yourself this
question: "how can SP3 possibly be 100% bug free and stable for
everyone?" Mathematicians clain they can prove that NO software
is or can be bug free so why risk a visit from Murphy if you're
already up-to-date and running just fine? Yes, yes, I know the OP
is not running just fine and SP3 might just help them ...