How to reference variable range?

[WhatsUp31415]

I have one column of data (B9:B721) and a parallel column of tags (C9:C721).
The data are arranged with all of "Tag1" data, followed by all of "Tag2"
data, etc.

I want to be able to reference all of the data for "Tag1", or all of the
data for "Tag2", etc. For example:

=FREQUENCY(tagrange,H1:H15)

Currently, I use INDIRECT to construct tagrange:

INDIRECT("B" & MIN(IF(C9:C721="TAG2",ROW(C9:C721))) &
":B" & MAX(IF(C9:C721="TAG2",ROW(C9:C721))))

Is there a better way?

The ideal variable reference would not require an array formula, as the
MIN/IF usage above does, even though the example, FREQUENCY, must be an
array formula anyway.

 

[Gary''s Student]

Your idea is clever. There are other ways, but they are not necessarily
"better". For example, a set of formulas like:

=SUMPRODUCT((B9:B721<H1)*(C9:C721="Tag2"))
=SUMPRODUCT((B9:B721>=H1)*(B9:B721<H2)*(C9:C721="Tag2"))

is another way, but is it "better" ?? Your technique works because your
data is pre-sorted by tag.

 

[Gary''s Student]

Your idea is clever. There are other ways, but they are not necessarily
"better". For example, a set of formulas like:

=SUMPRODUCT((B9:B721<H1)*(C9:C721="Tag2"))
=SUMPRODUCT((B9:B721>=H1)*(B9:B721<H2)*(C9:C721="Tag2"))

is another way, but is it "better" ?? Your technique works because your
data is pre-sorted by tag.

 

[T. Valko]

Couple of ways...

This method is shorter but is volatile (recalculates *every* time a
calculation is triggered):

G1 = TagX

=FREQUENCY(OFFSET(B9,MATCH(G1,C9:C721,0)-1,,COUNTIF(C9:C721,G1)),H1:H5)

This method is longer but isn't volatile:

=FREQUENCY(INDEX(B9:B721,MATCH(G1,C9:C721,0)):INDEX(B9:B721,MATCH(G1,C9:C721,0)+COUNTIF(C9:C721,G1)-1),H1:H5)

 

[T. Valko]

Couple of ways...

This method is shorter but is volatile (recalculates *every* time a
calculation is triggered):

G1 = TagX

=FREQUENCY(OFFSET(B9,MATCH(G1,C9:C721,0)-1,,COUNTIF(C9:C721,G1)),H1:H5)

This method is longer but isn't volatile:

=FREQUENCY(INDEX(B9:B721,MATCH(G1,C9:C721,0)):INDEX(B9:B721,MATCH(G1,C9:C721,0)+COUNTIF(C9:C721,G1)-1),H1:H5)

 

[WhatsUp31415]

=FREQUENCY(OFFSET(B9,MATCH(G1,C9:C721,0)-1,,COUNTIF(C9:C721,G1)),H1:H5)

Thanks. I had wanted to use OFFSET, but I could not make it work, even with
constants. I must have made some mistakes. In any case, I had not thought
of using MATCH.

This method is longer but isn't volatile:
=FREQUENCY(INDEX(B9:B721,MATCH(G1,C9:C721,0)):INDEX(B9:B721,MATCH(G1,C9:C721,0)+COUNTIF(C9:C721,G1)-1),H1:H5)

I like the fact that this is not volatile.

Thanks again. And thanks for understanding the question.

 

[WhatsUp31415]

=FREQUENCY(OFFSET(B9,MATCH(G1,C9:C721,0)-1,,COUNTIF(C9:C721,G1)),H1:H5)

Thanks. I had wanted to use OFFSET, but I could not make it work, even with
constants. I must have made some mistakes. In any case, I had not thought
of using MATCH.

This method is longer but isn't volatile:
=FREQUENCY(INDEX(B9:B721,MATCH(G1,C9:C721,0)):INDEX(B9:B721,MATCH(G1,C9:C721,0)+COUNTIF(C9:C721,G1)-1),H1:H5)

I like the fact that this is not volatile.

Thanks again. And thanks for understanding the question.

 

[T. Valko]

You're welcome. Thanks for the feedback!

 

[T. Valko]

You're welcome. Thanks for the feedback!