Does Dell make its own motherboards?

J

jas0n

But, YMMV, I'll personally never buy a Dell because today's convenience
becomes tomorrow's headache.


Why thank you. You too...

maybe ....

we went all compaq at work, desktops, servers, the lot .... almost 1000
systems spread over several sites across the country - compaq service
when parts fail has been outstanding - replacement warranty parts arrive
quickly .... if ive had to send a laptop away for board replacement or
whatever its back in less than a week after theyve collected it

i get a new compaq machine in and providing its working when I unpack it
(and have a ready ris image) it can be up and running in just over an
hour with w2k, office2k pro, winzip and acrobat reader and all its
patches using ris for OS install, group policy for the software install
and sus for the critical updates. use roaming profiles and WAN aware
logon scripts and theres not all that much for a standard office base
unit you have to configure. theres always the odd bit of software
specific to each dept but generally weve found it much better doing it
this way.

in a corporate environment it saves lots of time to standardise ...
compaq, now hp have been great for us over the last 3 years.
 
J

jas0n

(e-mail address removed), a.k.a Gama Chameleon
says...

Try getting the 'non-standard' components of HP's fixed out of
warranty...

there are out of warranty spares available for compaq/hp's - you just
need to know the suppliers ... its been a while since ive used them so I
cant recall but there are a few of them ... you may balk at the price
but compared to the complete replacement you say its still better to buy
the part in a lot of circumstances.
 
T

Tx2

The same is true from the kid down the street, or the sales chap in the
local mom-and-pop computer store - all sales people will tell the
customer what they need to hear in order to make the sale. Only a few
ethical sales people will tell them what they need to know and possibly
loose a sale if it means they are priced out of what they really need.

I am the latter, and have lost sales thru total honesty. I've been
thanked for that honesty, but have made the customer far more aware of
what they are doing. Invariably, i get a call some while later asking
for my help with matters further down the line, and my relationship with
that customer then grows based on the foundation of trust I laid down
from the start.
I'm not trying to change your mind - just would like you to understand
that in your limited experience

Sorry, but that reeks of pomposity, and I find it quite arrogant.
that it's not always like you state and that there are value
added ways to get the solution from the large
vendors with little additional cost. Also that a home-build, is not
always the proper solution, even for home users.

1. I didn't say it was always this way, i said in my experience it had
been. However, others here in this group have echoed doubts about Dell
UK

2. Large vendors rarely are interested in 'small fry' like me. You have
clout, you shift 1.3 million units a year.

3. I didn't say it was always the proper solution. For the clients i
advise, Dell has not been the preferred solution, and given i went thru
hell with one client recently when he was trying to buy a Dell, I'm not
prepared to damage my reputation further by recommending a vendor from
whom I have had nothing but bad experience.

My background is working for one of the largest companies in the world
heading a European Management Helpdesk. I have dealt with the biggest of
the big in corporate terms .... don't tell me I have limited experience
in IT Solutions. http://www.geitsolutions.com/
I've yet to run across a large vendors system that could not
be installed in a new case or a power supply purchased for it.

Then you haven't tried to service a Dell desktop in the UK.
Or tried to attach front connecting USB leads to a Hewlett Packard
machine built into a standard case then. I have.
And, whey they bought it, they didn't check to see what level of service
they would get, they didn't ask if there was a higher level, and they
didn't research on-line complaints before purchasing.

Ever heard of PC World here in the UK? The more you type, the more it
seems you are unclear as to how things run over here.
And neither can many system

Eh? I'm about to upgrade a homebuilt PC for one of my customers next
week. A new graphics card to support Direct X 9. the system is the best
part of 2 years old.
- if you want to have a gamer system you
don't buy Packard Bell anyways.

She wasn't buying a gamer system. She was buying a computer. The
salesman never warned her that the thing is completely useless so far as
upgrades or standard repairs are concerned.
I'm sure that it ran what she needed
when she bought it, why would anyone expect to be able to play some new
game on it now.

My PC is nearly 2 years old. I didn't intend playing games when I got
it. It was a business machine. I play Call of Duty on it now, in my
spare time, having upgraded the AGP card to accommodate such. Call it my
executive toy.
As for upgrades, she can always purchase a new
motherboard/CPU and case and keep the other parts from the PB, this
would be cheaper than a new box and give her another 18 months of
performance (until the next bloatware comes out).

You've never seen a Le Div@ have you ....
Anyone that spends $590 on a PC should not expect to be doing cutting
edge work with it now, and certainly not in 2 years. The entry point in
performance systems is well over $1500 for OS and hardware on a quality
system + 17" monitor. A system in that range will play all the current
games for about 12 months or until the next bloatware method comes
along. There are many people still running happily on Celeron 466 Dell
Optiplex 100 machines (more than 7 years old) and using XP Professional
and Office 2003 on them - and they are the micro case units. It's all
about buying what you need and needing what you've bought. If you buy
cheap you'll have to upgrade shortly - doesn't matter if it's a Dell or
a home built system.

It's late here in the UK, i'll digest that little lot later....

But, on first read, it seems to be similar to some of what I've already
said? Don't buy Dell on a budget, get a more versatile custom built and
upgradeable solution from the outset but at greater cost. In the long
run you'll yada yada....

Yep, that is what I was saying.
We always provide a proposal with costs and give them time to review it
with others if needed, we've never lost a sale yet, and many customers
want Dell, Gateway, HP/Compaq, but few want a custom build.

If you are shifting 1.3 million units a year, i suspect you don't place
much emphasis on supplying custom builds. You can shift the emphasis on
supporting those machines right back to where they came from. Good
business, but not at all suited to my way of trading.
We're not poles apart in circumstances, only experience.
Rubbish.

You don't have to respond, but, in a few years, if

when ...
your business grows, you will see that I've been right in this thread.

I haven't said you are wrong. I disagree with you telling me what is
best for my business, and my clients, but you have your viewpoint, i
have mine. Your arrogance is really quite overpowering, but, c'est la
vie. I don't agree with fuel guzzling Hummers, but it's your country and
I'm not going to tell you what you can and can't drive on the road.

My experience of Dell UK has been nothing but awful, so i choose not to
use them. You seem to not realise that.

I can, and do, provide a superior service to my customers over and above
what Dell would provide, they tell me so. Those who've had Dell etc had
said they wished they'd "found" me ages ago. I can only speak as I find.
I wish you much success in your endeavors and hope all goes well for
you

Likewise ...
 
T

Tx2

in a corporate environment it saves lots of time to standardise ...

I never said otherwise. i would never recommend a larger corporate
company do anything less.
compaq, now hp have been great for us over the last 3 years.

Compaq were always the best company to deal with when I was in corporate
IT.
 
T

Tx2

a.k.a says... said:
I agree, he must of spent at least an hour typing replies to these
posts, so I'd love to see him spend the 10-15 minutes speccing it up.

Why ... to prove what price I could do it for? What's the point?

I've already said I couldn't beat Dell. Not sure what it would achieve
to be honest. Ammunition for someone to take the piss? Sorry chum, I'm
not into playing silly games on usenet for the entertainment of others.

I've spent some time replying, yes, hardly an hour. It might have been,
if i was trying to be cocky and clever, but i've simply replied with a)
my experience, and b) spoken as i've found. If you don't agree with it,
there's not an awful lot I can do to change it.
 
T

Tx2

[...]
there are out of warranty spares available for compaq/hp's - you just
need to know the suppliers ...

Yes, Partsurfer is a good source for finding out what you need, and then
companies like Logitech will source it, but then you need to convince
the customer to pay the price. You forget, we (at least I am) are
talking small business / domestic user, not corporate budgets.
you may balk at the price but compared to the complete
replacement you say its still better to buy
the part in a lot of circumstances

What complete replacement? I said swapping some of the components into a
standard case was an option - did I type that a complete replacement was
as well?
 
L

Leythos

But, i'll knock spots off them with the after sales service I provide,
when the customer has issues with this, or issues with that, or needs
help with something else; and as I have customer testimonials to this
effect, that's satisfaction enough for me.

But your after sales support has a REAL cost, it's not free, at least
not if you plan on being a sole business owner for long. The after sale
follow-ups and support cost real money for any business, even yours, at
least if you place any value on your time.

So, while you (and I) give very personalized service to clients, I
happen to understand a little more about the hidden costs and the value
of a warranty and 24/7/365 support (even if it's not the greatest).
 
L

Leythos

If you are shifting 1.3 million units a year, i suspect you don't place
much emphasis on supplying custom builds. You can shift the emphasis on
supporting those machines right back to where they came from. Good
business, but not at all suited to my way of trading.

To clarify, it was 1.3 milling in sales, not units. I hope we never do
1.3 million units.

As for custom builds, I strongly encourage them and love the ASUS PC-DL
Deluxe motherboard. I've got about 30 of them running Dual Xeon CPU's
and 6 drive IDE RAID-5 arrays at 1.3TB of space with a RAID-1 250GB
space and 4GB of RAM - these run as production MS SQL servers and
production web servers in our office. The nice thing about the IDE RAID-
5 and RAID-1 units are they are on-line hot swappable. I've done the
same setups for several public utility companies to act as on-line
storage arrays or for on-line backup servers.

As for our office, I have a BUNCH of servers and workstations and
laptops. There is only 1 name brand laptop (a Toshiba 17" unit) and one
server (A ML350 dual P3/1ghz system) in the place. All our units are
hand built and selected from the best parts available at the time.
Selecting the parts takes hours of research each couple months as vendor
lots change and their reliability/compatibility changes the same.

When I was contacted to design an off-shore (India) development center I
spec'd the ASUS PC-DL Deluxe server board for all servers and Dell's for
workstations (the 650 series, dual SCSI drives....). The servers were a
fraction of the cost that a Dell would have been, but the workstations
needed to have the large support contract - it's one thing to have
internal support for a group of servers, but parts warranties for
hundreds of workstations is mandatory today. I did a small development
center on the other side of the country, 4 Dual Xeon servers (also ASUS)
and 6 workstations - they wanted Dell workstations, but loved the custom
servers, not one fault in more than a year on the Dells or the Servers.

I'm not doubting your experience with Dell, I've seen it before, but I'm
having problems with your cost/value side of the equation.

Anyway, have a good evening.
 
T

Tx2

But your after sales support has a REAL cost, it's not free, at least
not if you plan on being a sole business owner for long. The after sale
follow-ups and support cost real money for any business, even yours, at
least if you place any value on your time.

All built into the original pricing, or recouped from chargeable calls.
I place an emphasis on making money too you know.
So, while you (and I) give very personalized service to clients, I
happen to understand a little more about the hidden costs and the value
of a warranty and 24/7/365 support (even if it's not the greatest).

Well, i don't believe you do. I believe you think you know more about my
business model than me, but .... well, let's leave it there shall we.

</eot>
 
G

Gama Chameleon

And just who are they going to call for FREE? Unless you charge them for
phone support you are not comparing apples-to-apples. If you give phone
support for free, then you've built it into your hourly rate (or you are
loosing money on it).

That would have to be either factored into the original price or the
supoprt warranty. Much in the same way as shops do for items such as
TVs e.t.c.
 
G

Gama Chameleon

While you can argue that Dell does not provide the same value as your
self-built system in your experience, many of us, with far more
experience with far more vendors, can assure you that Dell (and the
others) do offer more value than your seeing on your end.

One also very important point is that unlike quite a few mom and pop
outfits, they are not going to go out of business the following year
either due to not being financially viable or doing the old close down
and open under a new name loop hole (leaving you in the lurch).

Round here I've seem small operations come and go on a yearly basis.
 
M

Mercury

So big names are immune to this then?
There are less of them. Most have crashed / been taken over / merged out of
existence.

Once there was the BUNCH. Burrows, Univac, NCR, Honeywell. Then IBM...
I haven't heard of Facom or Amdahl for yonks...
Oh, don't forget DEC, Compaq, Gateway made a big flop - is it still going?
Micron... Some names are different in other countries.

It depends on what you want, what you need, how much you are willing to pay,
where you are, service level you require, *toungue in cheek* how ignorant
you are, and what is available.
 
G

GB

Tx2 said:
Why ... to prove what price I could do it for? What's the point?

I've already said I couldn't beat Dell. Not sure what it would achieve
to be honest. Ammunition for someone to take the piss? Sorry chum, I'm
not into playing silly games on usenet for the entertainment of others.

I've spent some time replying, yes, hardly an hour. It might have been,
if i was trying to be cocky and clever, but i've simply replied with a)
my experience, and b) spoken as i've found. If you don't agree with it,
there's not an awful lot I can do to change it.

I'm sorry that this has all got rather personal. You made a sweeping
generalisation - that anyone buying Dell is an idiot - and not surprisingly
all the people who have bought Dell jumped down your throat. :)

There are clearly people who will benefit from your sort of hands-on support
and custom-built PCs. Reasonably technically-minded people, such as the
people on these NGs, are not your sort of customer though.

There is certainly an advantage in using standard parts, and I wish the
likes of Dell would do that. This is the main drawback of Dell (or HP/Compaq
for that matter).

There are significant savings in buying from Dell rather than you. (You
won't give any figures, but the PC I spec'd out cost 185 Pounds including
VAT and delivery from Dell recently, and I expect you would quite reasonably
want to charge over 300 Pounds.)

If I have to build up the systems myself, I would want to factor in my own
time plus the hassle of dealing with online component suppliers, so Dell
still works out much cheaper up-front.

The big snag (as you have pointed out frequently) is if something goes wrong
with one of the proprietary components, such as the PSU. That may mean
buying a new case, and possibly even a new mobo, as well as the new psu. Or
it may mean biting the bullet and paying Dell a silly price for their
replacement psu. Even so, there is probably enough saving in the original
purchase price to cover this. These PCs are pretty reliable in any case, so
it is quite likely not to be a problem.

I hope you now understand why it is a perfectly sensible choice for some
(non-idiotic) people to buy Dell.

Geoff
 
G

GB

While placing that order it was confirmed by Dell
that both the new and the old PSU did not have
standard ATX connections.

That is certainly my understanding, but I have never actually checked
myself. The wires are in a different order. Out of interest, how difficult
would it be to disassemble the ATX connector of a standard PSU and put the
wires into the order required by Dell?

I've got a cheapo PSU here that I've been fiddling with. I can't get the
little connector pins out of the ATX connector block. Is there a knack to
this, or are they intended to stay in forever?

Do you remember how many of the wires are different? My understanding was
that it was just a couple of wires that were swapped over. If it's only two,
I guess that it would be possible to cut the wires and splice them back
together in the right order.

Geoff
 
T

Tx2

(e-mail address removed), a.k.a Gama Chameleon
says...
One also very important point is that unlike quite a few mom and pop
outfits, they are not going to go out of business the following year
either due to not being financially viable or doing the old close down
and open under a new name loop hole (leaving you in the lurch).

Of course, again, you forget that a self-build PC is usually built from
off-the-shelf parts, and as such is very easily maintained.

Tiny were a PC manufacturer who went bust and left a lot of people in
the lurch due to the use of proprietary parts.

Any small time independent who goes out of business isn't going to have
the same impact on a business *if* they supplied 100% compliant ATX
systems.
Round here I've seem small operations come and go on a yearly basis

As no doubt you have builders, decorators and a myriad of other business
types. Going out of business isn't exclusive to IT Service companies,
nor does it exclude Dell.
 
T

Tx2

I hope you now understand why it is a perfectly sensible choice for some
(non-idiotic) people to buy Dell

Firstly, i don't recall every calling anyone who buys Dell an "idiot",
so please quote me correctly.

Secondly, i have, frequently, said that it is a case of each to their
own, but that I, personally, would not recommend Dell to my customers on
the basis of the experiences i have had.

In fact, on one of my posts i clearly wrote : "I'm not saying don't buy
Dell - I simply believe it to be a false economy to do so based on what
i've read here thus far"

My opinion hasn't changed that much since then.

I think you need to re-read what i have written, and then apologise for
suggesting I've made "sweeping statements"... and insulted people.

I have spoken as i find, factual, and from personal experience - and
then justified it.
 
G

GB

Tx2 said:
Firstly, i don't recall every calling anyone who buys Dell an "idiot",
so please quote me correctly.

Sorry, you are right - it was the poster before you, someone calling himself
Venom. :)

I think you need to re-read what i have written, and then apologise for
suggesting I've made "sweeping statements"... and insulted people.

Sorry about mixing you up with Venom.
 
M

Mercury

I worked on a 386 sx (?) for a while. Had a 8085 running CPM 1 in about 1981
with a whopping 5mb HDD and 64 kb ram. But then the mainframe I worked on
(which was huge) had 16mb ram, 2 processors, paper tape, punched cards, 14
tape decks, 28 HDD's (biggest was 600MB), etc...
 
L

Leythos

Once there was the BUNCH. Burrows, Univac, NCR, Honeywell. Then IBM...
I haven't heard of Facom or Amdahl for yonks...
Oh, don't forget DEC, Compaq, Gateway made a big flop - is it still going?
Micron... Some names are different in other countries.

And you could get support for those companies for years after they
merged or closed. I know for a fact that Burrows (which merged with
Sperry to become Unisys - which my wife worked for during my time time
in the Navy) provided support via Unisys after the merger. The same for
NCR and Homeywell... IBM is still around. DEC was still providing
support years after, same with Compaq, Gateway, and Micron. Micron,
while not producing PC's under their name any more still has support
under the new company....
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Top