Dispute about whether email was sent

[glendabray21]

Hi, I have someone claiming to have sent me an email.

He has produced a printed copy of the purported email but it only shows hisown name next to "From" and "To".

I have never received this email.

This matter is now in VCAT and he is trying to say that I am wrong and deliberately being misleading by saying the email was not received and explainsit by saying that the reference to his own name in the email is "simply a cc and happens when emails are shifted in Outlook from Sent Items to Files"..

He also claims the email was "system acknowledged".

I would have thought that if he had evidence i.e. a read receipt from me, he would have produced a copy of the sent email which shows the read date and time but he has not produced this.

My question - is there any way I can check via my Outlook any emails from this person which my Outlook has provided a read receipt for.

We exchanged many emails in the course of our business and we both always had them set to automatically request a read receipt which was always agreedto. I know I can locate all of his read receipts for emails I have sent, but wondering if there is a way I can check exactly what incoming emails from him have produced a read receipt from me.

Thanks in advance - hoping someone can help with this.

 

[badgolferman]

Hi, I have someone claiming to have sent me an email.

He has produced a printed copy of the purported email but it only
shows his own name next to "From" and "To".

I have never received this email.

This matter is now in VCAT and he is trying to say that I am wrong
and deliberately being misleading by saying the email was not
received and explains it by saying that the reference to his own name
in the email is "simply a cc and happens when emails are shifted in
Outlook from Sent Items to Files".

He also claims the email was "system acknowledged".

I would have thought that if he had evidence i.e. a read receipt from
me, he would have produced a copy of the sent email which shows the
read date and time but he has not produced this.

My question - is there any way I can check via my Outlook any emails
from this person which my Outlook has provided a read receipt for.

We exchanged many emails in the course of our business and we both
always had them set to automatically request a read receipt which was
always agreed to. I know I can locate all of his read receipts for
emails I have sent, but wondering if there is a way I can check
exactly what incoming emails from him have produced a read receipt
from me.

Thanks in advance - hoping someone can help with this.

If this is a work email then the Exchange Server should have a record
of the message. I would check with the IT people. Ask them why you
are not receiving these messages from this fellow and let them call him
a liar.