q_q said:
you have a license. AFAIK it's legal to download a 'dodgy' copy as
long as it is licensed.
Wow - where'd you get that?
A techie lawyer that also works in the field of software copyright.
He said it's all about the Paper, the license.
While it is true - it is all about the license - giving advice to download
(your word) "dodgy" software is irresponsible - at best. Not to mention
that the person doing the download would not only have to know how to setup
the applications to obtain the "warez" version of the software, understand
the dangers of downloading things from such a site and having P2P on the
machine and what could possible come with that and how to keep themselves
protected - but they also need to know what TYPE of Windows XP CD to
download - as their Key and EULA is for one TYPE of XP - OEM, Upgrade,
Retail, MSDN, etc...
I wouldn't hide things on the basis that the person is not smart
enough to learn. Stunting his knowledge. Perhaps I should've
mentioned the risks though. e.g. spyware and viruses- incase he
hasn't heard of those!
The guy plans on installing windows from a CD. If he wants to be
capable of that then doesn't that indicate that he wouldn't want to
stunt his knowledge at such an early point. I'd have thought he
aspires to be computer literate enough to have the ability to do the
things I suggested. And I don't think that the things I suggested
require more ability than he is capable of or even that they acquire
much more skill than the skill he has now.
Never said the OP shouldn't learn - but - yes - you have obviously gone
beyond what the OP knows already - and you are leading them down a path that
is more likely to get them in more trouble at their skill level than less.
You assume that someone who is about to reinstall (not repair, not clean,
none of that) due to (their words) "downloading file issues" is ready to be
told, "Here - get one of these methods of downloading "questionable"
software shared out by anyone and their mother on any computer in the world
(infected/infested unknowns) and download a Windows XP CD to use in place of
yours."? Again - sounds irresponsible - at best - to me... Especially when
there is a responsible and 100% legitimate method by which the OP can
accomplish the task. (And has chosen to do so.)