The Bottom Five of 2001
By John C. Dvorak, Computer Shopper
October 5, 2001
Once again, I've been given the assignment of identifying the five worst products or ideas of the last 12 months or so. Keeping the list to five is always a challenge. As usual, certain technologies and ideas on the edge of failure, such as Rambus memory or the Sony Memory Stick, are a temptation to list, allowing me to be the first to say, "I told you so!" But I refuse to give in. The fact is, some seriously bad ideas and products emerged this year. Here then is this year's final list, in no particular order:
1. The Epson Smart Cartridge
If anything is going to kill the momentum of Epson and its incredible piezoelectric inkjet technology, it's this ridiculous addition. Epson, in its newer printers, has put intelligence in the cartridges and printer mechanism to foil third-party ink suppliers. While this chip in the cartridge is supposed to monitor ink usage, it's really designed to let the printer know that an "alien" cartridge has been installed. Many of these third-party cartridges are used by professional photographers for special purposes such as true black-and-white printing. Perhaps it's time for printer companies to drop the idea of selling printers below cost in some sort of razor-and-razor-blade scheme.