Geoff said:
What do people think about downloading software and other stuff from a peer
to peer networker like Kazaa? They assure you on their site that it's
totally legal. How can this be?
The Kazaa application, in and of itself (if one doesn't consider the
spyware that one agrees to have installed along with it), and the
concept of peer-to-peer networking *are* perfectly legal. It's the use
to which so many people put Kazaa that results in the illegalities.
Think of it this way: A kitchen paring knife, in and of itself, is a
perfectly legitimate and innocuous tool for anyone to own and use, when
it's used for its designed purpose, peeling fruit and vegetables. If,
however, one were to use that knife for some illegal purpose, such as
attacking and injuring an annoying spouse/child/neighbor, is the knife
at fault?
Granted, the developers of Kazaa know perfectly well that their product
will primarily be used for the purposes of illegally distributing
copyrighted material, but they have what's known in political circles as
"plausible deniability." Because there are some legitimate uses to
which Kazaa can be put, its develops can successfully argue that it's
not their fault that people misuse the tool they've provided. They're
correct, but hardly innocent. If the developers of Kazaa were as
innocent and altruistic as they have their users believe, why is their
product full of spyware and adware?
--
Bruce Chambers
Help us help you:
You can have peace. Or you can have freedom. Don't ever count on having
both at once. - RAH