H.D. Swap on a P4C800ED

  • Thread starter Janet Herringshaw
  • Start date
J

Janet Herringshaw

After investigating every cause I can think of for spontaneous reboots on a
P4C800ED I would like to swap out the motherboard with a new one. I have new
memory and a P4e3.0gig that I would install at the same time. There are a
lot of programs installed on the original drive C hard disk and I wonder if
I can just install that? I haven't done this for years and the last time
seem to remember it didn't work.

So-- The O.S. is XPPro SP2. Can I expect that to work okay with a new
motherboard and cpu or is it reformat and re-install time?


--
(e-mail address removed)
Janet Herringshaw
MD2MD
Pescadero, CA
650-879-0546
 
J

Joe Schmuckatelli

So-- The O.S. is XPPro SP2. Can I expect that to work okay with a new
motherboard and cpu or is it reformat and re-install time?

Before shutting down the system for the last time, you'll need to make
a few changes in Device Manager, preferably in Safe Mode.

Change the master ide controller to "Standard Dual PCI IDE
Controller", and both the Primary and Secondary IDE channels to
"Standard IDE/ESDI Controller" (or something like that). Then shut
down and swap the board. Once you power up, you'll need to wait a few
minutes while XP redetects everything.

It should *not* be necessary to do a wipe and a reload.


--
-------------------------------------------------+-------------------
"One World; One Web; One Program." -- Microsoft | OS/2 Warp
| Solid like Linux
"Ein Volk; Ein Reich; Ein Führer." -- Hitler | Easy like Windows
-------------------------------------------------+-------------------

Use your bandwidth. If you don't, it'll go stale.

If Bill Gates had a dime for every time a Windows box
crashed... oh, wait. He does.

I Am Not A Number... Um...except for my TCP/IP address.

If you can read this .sig, you're too damn close.

Save a cow. Eat a vegetarian!

Remember, EVIL spelled backwards is LIVE -- and we all want to do that!

Dark Days in Human History: Hiroshima'45 Chernobyl'86 Windows'95

Proud member of the Signature is Longer Than The Post Association

--------------------------------------------------------------------
 
R

Ronald Cole

I'm considering buying this m/b and would like to put the fastest CPU
and RAM I can on it, but the manual is a bit confusing.

If I read it correctly, I should be able to drop the latest LGA775
Pentium 4 EE (the 3.73 GHz Prescott 1066MHz FSB) in with four sticks
of Samsung M378T6453FG0-CE6.

Also, that CPU supports EM64T, correct? So I should be able to run
Windows XP Professional x64 Edition on it, right? Is there any reason
I wouldn't want to? If not, which video card with STABLE 64-bit
drivers is recommended?

Is setting AI Overclocking and DRAM Frequency to "Auto" enough to get
such a system to detect that it can run at FSB 1066 and actually do
so?

Thanks in advance!
 
D

DaveW

If you change the motherboard in an XP OS computer, then you MUST reformat
the harddrive and reinstall the OS. Otherwise you will suffer ongoing nasty
Registry errors and data corruption.
 
T

Tim

If one does a repair install, none of what is detailed below is necessary as
the Hardware PNP detection is rerun and reconfigured.

I recommend you do not do this as there is always the chance you want to
regress, and that you could stuff up the regedit. I recall that this advice
originated from Win9x swapout procedures - that is where it belongs.

Further, this is far from a complete or satisfactory answer - one would have
to know all the hardware differences to be able to be sure that the slate is
clean enough and a Repair install is safe.

Always backup (take an image) before doing a repair.

- Tim
 
T

Tim

Dave, its time for you to do a repair and actually learn what it does, and
that this incessantly incorrect advice is tiresome.

- Tim
 
P

(Pete Cresswell)

Per DaveW:
If you change the motherboard in an XP OS computer, then you MUST reformat
the harddrive and reinstall the OS. Otherwise you will suffer ongoing nasty
Registry errors and data corruption.

Same thing for 2000 Pro?
 
P

Paul

Ronald Cole said:
I'm considering buying this m/b and would like to put the fastest CPU
and RAM I can on it, but the manual is a bit confusing.

If I read it correctly, I should be able to drop the latest LGA775
Pentium 4 EE (the 3.73 GHz Prescott 1066MHz FSB) in with four sticks
of Samsung M378T6453FG0-CE6.

Also, that CPU supports EM64T, correct? So I should be able to run
Windows XP Professional x64 Edition on it, right? Is there any reason
I wouldn't want to? If not, which video card with STABLE 64-bit
drivers is recommended?

Is setting AI Overclocking and DRAM Frequency to "Auto" enough to get
such a system to detect that it can run at FSB 1066 and actually do
so?

Thanks in advance!

Normally I'd suggest starting with the processorfinder.intel.com
web page, but not all the processors seem to be properly listed
there.

If you start at the processor product page:

http://www.intel.com/products/processor/index.htm?iid=HPAGE+header_products_processors&

then go to the extreme edition page, it says EM64T support is
there. (I prefer to see the support listed versus the exact model
of processor, as web pages like this are likely not updated
frequently.)

http://www.intel.com/products/processor/pentium4HTXE/index.htm

Proof of EM64T is in the datasheet for the 3.73GHz/FSB1066 processor.
http://download.intel.com/design/Pentium4/datashts/30638201.pdf

This Intel chipset page says DDR2-533 CAS3? is what Intel considers
the top performance level...

http://www.intel.com/products/chipsets/925xe/index.htm

The natural (1:1) clock ratio would be FSB1066 and DDR2-533. Both
use 266MHz clock. The Asus motherboard manual mentions support
for DDR2-711, which is a 3:4 ratio from CPU to memory. I think this
comes from Intel's support for both DDR2-400 and DDR2-533 when the
FSB is FSB800 - the 3:4 ratio comes from the attempt to support
DDR2-533 at FSB800. Then, when you run at FSB1066, the supported
memory speeds should become DDR2-533 and DDR2-711.

This Samsung page lists your 512MB memory choice as 5-5-5 memory
at DDR2-667.

http://www.samsung.com/Products/Sem.../UnbufferedDIMM/M378T6453FG0/M378T6453FG0.htm

Here are some alternate memories:

DDR2-800 at 5-5-5-10, available as 2x512MB or 2x1024MB.

http://www.ocztechnology.com/products/memory/ocz_ddr2_pc2_6400_gold_dual_channel

DDR2-800 at 4-3-3-8, available as 2x512MB

http://www.ocztechnology.com/produc...6400_platinum_enhanced_bandwidth_dual_channel

The only comparison of two versus four DIMMs I can find.
http://www.anandtech.com/mb/showdoc.aspx?i=2288&p=3

This article compares running at 711 versus 533, and winrar
gets a 2% performance improvement from the faster memory.
This article also explains what memory settings are available.

http://www.tomshardware.com/cpu/20041101/index.html

Anandtech reviews performance of some low latency DDR2.
http://www.anandtech.com/memory/showdoc.aspx?i=2306

An earlier review of first gen DDR2, suggesting overclocking
works very well with DDR2 memories.
http://www.anandtech.com/memory/showdoc.aspx?i=2112

It is possible four sticks of the lower latency RAM will run
at the same settings as two sticks of the higher latency
RAM (of the OCZ found above - and assuming a +1 CAS
latency penalty for using four DIMMs). It is too bad that
Wesley did not list the command rate when running four sticks,
or provide even a memtest86 bandwidth reading for that config,
so we could get some idea of whether the chipset suffers
a penalty with four sticks.

With the memory ratings not lining up with the motherboard
settings, it makes it very hard to find just
the right combination of RAM to use. 2x1024 would be a
desirable RAM configuration, if some with decent latency
could be found. Maybe those 5-5-5 DDR2-800 ones above would
be the least hassle to use, if 711 was your only target.
The OCZ-4200EB 3-2-2-8 2x1024MB memory could be run at
DDR2-533, leaving DDR2-711 as an overclocking experiment.
I cannot find enough review data to decide which is the best
course of action.

The FSB1066 processor has three BSEL pins on the bottom. They
automatically encode FSB1066 as the desired operating
frequency. But, I would never trust totally automatic settings.
At the very least, get a copy of CPUZ and verify that the BIOS
is setting the frequencies and memory timings according to the
manufacturer's specs. Depending on which memory strategy you
use, you could spend quite a bit of time tuning the memory
manually for best performance. The DDR2-800 5-5-5 memory
would be close to automatic, but not very aggressive. (I.e.
Asus may not select DDR2-711 by default, but may require the
user to switch from a default of DDR2-533. So, you may have
at least one setting to make, to get memory running at 711.
I doubt that decision would be automatically done for you.)

Post back with your experiences, as there is not a lot of
info on DDR2 to be had.

HTH,
Paul
 
G

Gert B. Frob

Janet Herringshaw said:
After investigating every cause I can think of for spontaneous reboots on a
P4C800ED I would like to swap out the motherboard with a new one. I have new
memory and a P4e3.0gig that I would install at the same time. There are a
lot of programs installed on the original drive C hard disk and I wonder if
I can just install that? I haven't done this for years and the last time
seem to remember it didn't work.

So-- The O.S. is XPPro SP2. Can I expect that to work okay with a new
motherboard and cpu or is it reformat and re-install time?


--
(e-mail address removed)
Janet Herringshaw
MD2MD
Pescadero, CA
650-879-0546


http://support.microsoft.com/default.aspx?scid=kb;en-us;824125
 
J

Joe Schmuckatelli

I recommend you do not do this as there is always the chance you want to
regress, and that you could stuff up the regedit. I recall that this advice
originated from Win9x swapout procedures - that is where it belongs.

Win2K, actually. Resetting the IDE controllers is not necessary with
Win9x. Not sure about NT 3/4.
Further, this is far from a complete or satisfactory answer - one would have
to know all the hardware differences to be able to be sure that the slate is
clean enough and a Repair install is safe.

Perhaps, perhaps not. I still stand by my answer.
Always backup (take an image) before doing a repair.

Agreed. A wise precaution no matter which route one decides to take.


--
-------------------------------------------------+-------------------
"One World; One Web; One Program." -- Microsoft | OS/2 Warp
| Solid like Linux
"Ein Volk; Ein Reich; Ein Führer." -- Hitler | Easy like Windows
-------------------------------------------------+-------------------

Use your bandwidth. If you don't, it'll go stale.

If Bill Gates had a dime for every time a Windows box
crashed... oh, wait. He does.

I Am Not A Number... Um...except for my TCP/IP address.

If you can read this .sig, you're too damn close.

Save a cow. Eat a vegetarian!

Remember, EVIL spelled backwards is LIVE -- and we all want to do that!

Dark Days in Human History: Hiroshima'45 Chernobyl'86 Windows'95

Proud member of the Signature is Longer Than The Post Association

--------------------------------------------------------------------
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Top