Best DVD format for the NEC 2510 DVD-Burner?

G

Gameface

Can anyone help me - I'm looking to buy one of the new dual-layer burners -
as the new media won't be out for a few weeks I just wanted to know what is
the next best format to buy (DVD-R or DVD+R) in both quality & value for
money.

Thanks
 
J

John

Can anyone help me - I'm looking to buy one of the new dual-layer burners -
as the new media won't be out for a few weeks I just wanted to know what is
the next best format to buy (DVD-R or DVD+R) in both quality & value for
money.

Thanks

Doesnt really matter. The more important thing is what quality is the
specific make of DVD and how compatible it is with your burner. In the
early days of CD burners there was a lot more compatibilty issues -
specific makers and brand of burner. Now you run into it sometimes but
in general my Liteons and even generic brands can burn almost
anything.

NECs are known to burn to a wide variety of media but DVD burners
havent been around as long as cd burners. The optorites and other
brands had lots of compatiblity problems you could see from the posts
at various sites and all the brands had and probably still have some
issues with some brands.

My 1300 NEC had big problems with the early white vinyl top COMPUSA
branded disks but not the silver top ones. They seem to have improved
the quality of the COMPUSAwhite vinyls and I dont have any problems
now. When I was throwing away the early white vinyl tops I bent them
to crack them to throwaway in the rubbish and they came apart really
easily. DVD disks are kind of a sandwich and the layers came apart
really easily with those. The ones I got recenty I threw away one and
it was very difficult to crack and it didnt come apart.

The Khypermedias - I hate to bash them because they look physically
well made in terms of not coming apart and people tend to bash them
relexively because they were often given away or sold at deep discount
after rebate. I dont know if its my NEC and NECs as I said are one of
the better DVD burners in terms of compatiblity - they tend to produce
a lot more coasters than other brands.I thought it would be another
compatibility thing - like the white vinyl COMPUSAs and things would
get better as NEC adjusted the firmware. I have the latest firmware
and overall Id say the Khypers are just a bit spotty. Not only have I
had a lot more coasters overall than COMPUSA brands, Philips,
HP and some other brands --- I checked a few Khypers two nights ago
and to my horror the data was all corrupted on them. Im going to
recheck all my burned Khypers tonight . A real pain the ass.

Ive seen a few warnings on packs Ive received - a pack of Khypers that
said dont use on Pioneers unless you got the latest firmware and a
spindle of some online stuff that said they wont work with the NEC
1300s - so there are still compatiblity issues going on. Also the 4x
Khypers I got recently on sale - they burned OK but my two older DVD
roms wont recognize them at all, all the other brands 2x stuff work on
them. Overall Im kind of down on Khypers right now and sticking with
the generic white COMPUSAs as my cheapo brand.
 
D

Doug Ramage

Gameface said:
Can anyone help me - I'm looking to buy one of the new dual-layer burners -
as the new media won't be out for a few weeks I just wanted to know what is
the next best format to buy (DVD-R or DVD+R) in both quality & value for
money.

Thanks

I have the 2500A model, and use 4x Verbatim dvd-r which can be burned at
8x - I assume that the 2510A has the same capability. But some 8x media has
dropped in price below the 4x Verbatims, although I have not tried any yet.
 
S

steeler

Doug Ramage said:
I have the 2500A model, and use 4x Verbatim dvd-r which can be burned at
8x - I assume that the 2510A has the same capability. But some 8x media has
dropped in price below the 4x Verbatims, although I have not tried any yet.
--

I got some samples of the grey top 8x dtatsafe "fuji" dye. Seems to be
close to ritek for compatability. Going for about £8.99 for 25.
 
D

Dave

Gameface said:
Can anyone help me - I'm looking to buy one of the new dual-layer burners -
as the new media won't be out for a few weeks I just wanted to know what is
the next best format to buy (DVD-R or DVD+R) in both quality & value for
money.

Thanks

Get dvd-r disks with a ritek g04/g05 dye.
 
D

Doug Ramage

steeler said:
I got some samples of the grey top 8x dtatsafe "fuji" dye. Seems to be
close to ritek for compatability. Going for about £8.99 for 25.

I was looking at these (from SVP?). Have they performed OK?
 
S

steeler

Doug Ramage said:
I was looking at these (from SVP?). Have they performed OK?
--

Sample was 10 discs. 8 burned so far (4 DVD, 2 PC data, 2 Xbox backup) -
all fine no coasters, no skips, etc. and the graphs look very similar to
ritek. Until ritek 8x drop in price I will be using these from now on.
 
J

J-A-K-E

Ref: 8x datatsafe "fuji" dye

SVP told me they would only Burn at 4x .........Anyone confirm?
 
R

Raiden

Gameface said:
Can anyone help me - I'm looking to buy one of the new dual-layer burners -
as the new media won't be out for a few weeks I just wanted to know what is
the next best format to buy (DVD-R or DVD+R) in both quality & value for
money.

Thanks

I guess SVP could always answer your question if you email them, maybe.

Going OT here slightly but I am considering one of these drives, can anyone
answer the following?

1) What is the fastest that Dual Layer drives will go to? I have been told
that something like 8 or 16x is the theoretical maximum for the current non
Dual Layer burners. Or is this BS?

2) The previous drive from NEC that isn't Dual Layer but can be made so via
firmware upgrade - has this been done successfully without problems yet?

TIA
 
D

Dave

Raiden said:
dual-layer
burners - wanted to know what
is

I guess SVP could always answer your question if you email them, maybe.

Going OT here slightly but I am considering one of these drives, can anyone
answer the following?

1) What is the fastest that Dual Layer drives will go to? I have been told
that something like 8 or 16x is the theoretical maximum for the current non
Dual Layer burners. Or is this BS?

12x is the current fastest i believe (but i havent seen one
available in the uk yet) 16x looks possible.
2) The previous drive from NEC that isn't Dual Layer but can be made so via
firmware upgrade - has this been done successfully without problems yet?

The firmware update works, only prob i know about is that on
some machines when you turn your computer on the drive
opens...... annoying, but hardly anything to panic about.
 
S

steeler

Dave said:
12x is the current fastest i believe (but i havent seen one
available in the uk yet) 16x looks possible.

Drives on the market are mostly 8x (comercial prices anyway)


The firmware update works, only prob i know about is that on
some machines when you turn your computer on the drive
opens...... annoying, but hardly anything to panic about.

firmware works but as no media is available no tests can be run.
 
D

Dave

steeler said:
Drives on the market are mostly 8x (comercial prices anyway)

Sony are apparantly going to release a 12x dual layer burner shortly
(i expect that to be around 200 quid :(( )
firmware works but as no media is available no tests can be run.

Dual layer media is available overseas (specifically in asia) and
apparantly it has been tested and works on the upgraded nec drive,
though i dont always trust dodgy taiwanese to english translation on
the web. We shall see if its true in the next couple of months :)
 
A

Adam H

Ref: 8x datatsafe "fuji" dye
SVP lie. I tested 8 all at 8x

I just bought a 2510 and a pack of DataSafe 8x, and they will only burn at
4x. Maybe I need a firmware upgrade? I would have thought a new 8x drive
would come with the appropriate version, though. Does anybody know where I
can get an official 2510 firmware? NEC's site is useless.
 
S

Shevek

I just bought a 2510 and a pack of DataSafe 8x, and they will only burn at
4x. Maybe I need a firmware upgrade? I would have thought a new 8x drive
would come with the appropriate version, though. Does anybody know where I
can get an official 2510 firmware? NEC's site is useless.

www.herrie.org lists the official as well as hacked firmwares - not
sure about the 2510 tho...

also try www.firmware-flash.com

HTH
 
A

Adam H

www.herrie.org lists the official as well as hacked firmwares - not
sure about the 2510 tho...

also try www.firmware-flash.com

HTH

Herrie didn't have any 2510s, and firmware-flash only had a region hacked
one, and I have had terrible experiences with hacked firmwares in the past,
so I am not too interested in that one. Thanks for the quick reply, though.
I just sent an email off to NEC, so I hope they will have an answer for
me... in 3 weeks or so :)
 
S

Shevek

Herrie didn't have any 2510s, and firmware-flash only had a region hacked
one, and I have had terrible experiences with hacked firmwares in the past,
so I am not too interested in that one. Thanks for the quick reply, though.
I just sent an email off to NEC, so I hope they will have an answer for
me... in 3 weeks or so :)

I assume you got to this page?

http://www.necd.de/softwareoverview2.php/id/557

If it's not on there I'm not sure there is one yet...
 
P

Psych

Sony are apparantly going to release a 12x dual layer burner shortly
(i expect that to be around 200 quid :(( )

sorry, but you mean dual format, not layer.

i'd iagine that the liteon would be cheaper,
seeing as they manufature the sony's (price premium) as well.

also i believe that benq, and a few other manufacturers have stated that
they'd offer free firmware upgrades to dual layer for some models of
exisitng drives. could be worth investigating.

and if anyone wants the sony dual layer drive, they might want to
investigate the latest standard gigabyte drive, same internals, and a much
cheaper price. firmware upgrade and you're laughing.


the only real question about these dual layer disks is compatibility. all
the online tests i've seen haven't looked too favourable with regards to pc
drives.

pesonally i'm waiting to see what lg does. a dual layer, triple format
drive will be hard to resist, espeially when it'll be cheaper than the big
brands
..
<snip>
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Top