Mike said:
No, because the Upgrade version - as its name implies - must be
installed on a PC that has an eligible version of Windows on it that
you can upgrade from.
Sorry, this is incorrect.. First the requirement to use an upgrade version
is to *own* a previous qualifying version's installation CD, not to have it
installed. When setup doesn't find a previous qualifying version installed,
it will prompt you to insert its CD as proof of ownership. Just insert the
previous version's CD, and follow the prompts. Everything proceeds quite
normally and quite legitimately.
As long as he has a previous qualifying version, either installed or on CD,
to qualify for the upgrade, he can do this.
Chances are that it's not even SP1 or SP2 version of XP so you'd
have to do a massive system update after using it to update
I'm not sure why you think it's likely to be a pre-SP1 version, but even if
it were, that wouldn't be a problem. Yes, he'd have to download (if he
didn't already have it) SP2 and install it, but that's not a problem.