ByTor said:
Hey Rick....Quick question.
I've never used windows to format, it actually forces NTFS after 32?
Just curious, if you know, why would XP do that when other partitioning
software allows FAT32 for an entire drive like that? Is it just a
limitation from "within" windows or is it something just designed that's
done for simplicity for the average user in mind?
ByTor:
To my knowledge there has never been a clear explanation from Microsoft as
to why they've imposed that 32 GB FAT32 partitioning/formatting limitation
in Windows XP. As far as I'm aware, there's no fundamental technical
restriction in the basic construction of XP that would prevent that OS from
overcoming that 32 GB barrier. It would seem that this was simply a built-in
limitation imposed on that OS by design. Perhaps it was Microsoft's way to
discourage the use of the FAT32 file system rather than the NTFS file
system.
As you know, one can still use a Win9x/Me Startup Disk or other bootable DOS
floppy disk or CD containing the FDISK/FORMAT commands to partition/format a
drive of any size in FAT32. And there's even a simple way that I learned a
few months ago to do this from *within* the XP environment! If you, or
anyone is interested in this, please so indicate.
Anna
ByTor responds...
Thank You Anna, very well put....just about what I was seeking,
especially the last sentence in your 1st paragraph....Makes sense. Ever
since XP came out I assume all proprietery machines are pre-imaged with
NTFS anyway so why not keep it consistent.........
I have PartitionMagic on all my machines so basically I can manipulate
PT's any way I like from XP, 2K, anywhere just about.....But I'd still
like to know your little secret..... ;0)
ByTor:
It's not my "little secret". Actually, it was brought to my attention by a
posting to this newsgroup some months ago. I failed to record the poster's
name. But it just occurred to me that this program's primary use (which I
failed to make clear in my last posting) is formatting an *external hard
drive* of any size in FAT32 from within the XP environment. As you know,
XP's 32 GB barrier prevents formatting a EHD > 32 GB and you can't use the
FDISK/FORMAT commands available on a DOS bootable floppy disk to do so.
While the program can be used to similarly format an *internal* drive within
the XP environment, it's really just as easy to accomplish that objective
with a DOS bootable floppy disk, e.g., a Win9x/Me Startup Disk. So this
capability might not be of any significant interest to you or others. But
let me know if it is and I'll provide the details.
Just one other thing... The program I speak of is *not* a conversion
program, i.e., converting NTFS to FAT32. It's strictly a formatting program.
Anna