So is the animosity only against recruiters or is it against any job
opening declaration on the newsgroup? I think it would be fine for
legitimate companies who need good C# coders to post openings on this
newsgroup. I don't think we'd see that many.
The exact degree and nature of the animosity surely is as varied as the
number of people using the newsgroup.
That said, in my own case it's my opinion that the newsgroup should be
used for on-topic posts only. This newsgroup is for questions about
the C# programming language, and by popular convention and extension
about .NET questions as well.
I don't personally feel that job announcements fall into those things.
To me, the metric is: if the proportion of messages increased to 50% or
more, would those messages still fit in? If not, they are off-topic
and should not be posted in any number, however small.
There are a variety of reasons to hold that position, but IMHO the
primary one is simply to avoid the possibility of the number of
messages increasing to a point where they interfere with the intended
use of the newsgroup. The identity of the person posting the
information has nothing to do with this risk.
Now, that said...to me the big issue is people who have nothing to do
with the newsgroup other than to post such an announcement. If someone
who was a regular user of the newsgroup, especially if they are a
regular contributor, had a specific staffing need or knew of one in
some personal context (e.g. the team they work for) and wanted to
mention that, I wouldn't find that nearly so objectionable as people
who post without any connection to the newsgroup except to use it as
their free head-hunting forum.
So, in answer to your specific question: "legitimate companies"? No
different than recruiters, IMHO. Those should be discouraged just as
much as recruiters (and in fact there's often no difference, some most
larger companies have their own recruiting staff). But that's not to
say that no one should ever post information about a job opening. It
just means it should be incredibly rare and should be done only by
people with an existing relationship to the newsgroup.
Pete