PC Review


Reply
Thread Tools Rate Thread

P4BGL-MX/533 and RTL8139 and Ghost

 
 
Robert Sudbury
Guest
Posts: n/a
 
      2nd Nov 2003
At work we're rolling out our first non-Intel based onboard nic mobos in
years, the Asus P4BGL-MX/533.

The latest available ndis2 driver from RealTek for the RTL8139 in DOS (3.24)
has issues... or is it the chip... or the power supplies... or mobo itself?

We use Ghost7 Enterprise for pushing the desktop images. At first I thought
the issues may be related to the 3Com 1100/3300 switches in between the
clients and the server but no.

These machines fail the ghost PUSH process either immediately or whenever,
when connected via 10Mb, full or half duplex... guaranteed. They will also
fail a manual ghost download via a DOS boot disk and the 3.24 ndis2 driver,
but uploads are okay.

When connected at 100Mb, it's a crap shoot whether PUSH will work, but
manually connecting via ndis2 driver 3.24 works up and down... though the
speed at 100Mb never goes over 200MB/min. Considering these are 1.7GHz
Celerons, we should expect considerably higher. Even attempts to push a
single client can and does fail with no other devices on the network and a
dedicated pipe from the server to that single client.

Cabling has been ruled out as a possibility. This is happening at all sites
these machines are going into, with many different network configurations,
loads etc... Meanwhile all Intel based connections fly as usual.

Does anyone have an ndis2 dos driver for this RealTek PHY that is optimized
for Ghost and works at all connection speeds?

--
]Robert[ remove "ALLOF YOURCLOTHES" to reply


 
Reply With Quote
 
 
 
 
Paul
Guest
Posts: n/a
 
      3rd Nov 2003
In article <rgfpb.3429$(E-Mail Removed)>, "Robert Sudbury"
<(E-Mail Removed)> wrote:

> At work we're rolling out our first non-Intel based onboard nic mobos in
> years, the Asus P4BGL-MX/533.
>
> The latest available ndis2 driver from RealTek for the RTL8139 in DOS (3.24)
> has issues... or is it the chip... or the power supplies... or mobo itself?
>
> We use Ghost7 Enterprise for pushing the desktop images. At first I thought
> the issues may be related to the 3Com 1100/3300 switches in between the
> clients and the server but no.
>
> These machines fail the ghost PUSH process either immediately or whenever,
> when connected via 10Mb, full or half duplex... guaranteed. They will also
> fail a manual ghost download via a DOS boot disk and the 3.24 ndis2 driver,
> but uploads are okay.
>
> When connected at 100Mb, it's a crap shoot whether PUSH will work, but
> manually connecting via ndis2 driver 3.24 works up and down... though the
> speed at 100Mb never goes over 200MB/min. Considering these are 1.7GHz
> Celerons, we should expect considerably higher. Even attempts to push a
> single client can and does fail with no other devices on the network and a
> dedicated pipe from the server to that single client.
>
> Cabling has been ruled out as a possibility. This is happening at all sites
> these machines are going into, with many different network configurations,
> loads etc... Meanwhile all Intel based connections fly as usual.
>
> Does anyone have an ndis2 dos driver for this RealTek PHY that is optimized
> for Ghost and works at all connection speeds?


The Celeron has to copy the data via block move from a receive buffer
into a space the rest of the software stack can use it. It could then
be copied via DMA. The RTL8129/39 are not high performance ethernet
devices, so are probably incapable of keeping up with the data rate.

http://www.scyld.com/pipermail/realt...st/001468.html
http://www.corega.co.jp/product/os/source/rtl8139.c

You didn't mention it, but you are probably multicasting. Maybe
the source machine should have a lower performance than the destination
machine(s), so there is less chance of dropping packets at the
dest. Maybe there is a network throttling parameter in Windows
for the source machine ?

Just guesses,
Paul
 
Reply With Quote
 
Robert Sudbury
Guest
Posts: n/a
 
      3rd Nov 2003
Thanks for the links. That first one has some juicy bits.

As it happens, the source server is running slower than the client machines,
but again, there is no problem dealing with any version of Intel's 100+
NICs, or even Digital 21041, and 3Com's.

This is very obviously a RealTek issue. The problems these other people
described mirror almost exactly what we're experiencing. This gives me some
ideas about perhaps tweaking the BIOS on the mobos to see if preference can
be given to the onboard lan, irq... Though I don't remember seeing anything
useful like that in the BIOS... or maybe even the usb mouse.

Yes we are multicasting. With 80 LANs on the WAN, that's the point.
Altering the configuration of these networks when they already work
wonderfully for everything else, for what is now obviously an inferior part,
is probably out of the question.

--
]Robert[ remove "ALLOF YOURCLOTHES" to reply
"Paul" <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message
news:nospam-0211032244500001@192.168.1.177...
> In article <rgfpb.3429$(E-Mail Removed)>, "Robert Sudbury"
> <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote:
>
> > At work we're rolling out our first non-Intel based onboard nic mobos in
> > years, the Asus P4BGL-MX/533.
> >
> > The latest available ndis2 driver from RealTek for the RTL8139 in DOS

(3.24)
> > has issues... or is it the chip... or the power supplies... or mobo

itself?
> >
> > We use Ghost7 Enterprise for pushing the desktop images. At first I

thought
> > the issues may be related to the 3Com 1100/3300 switches in between the
> > clients and the server but no.
> >
> > These machines fail the ghost PUSH process either immediately or

whenever,
> > when connected via 10Mb, full or half duplex... guaranteed. They will

also
> > fail a manual ghost download via a DOS boot disk and the 3.24 ndis2

driver,
> > but uploads are okay.
> >
> > When connected at 100Mb, it's a crap shoot whether PUSH will work, but
> > manually connecting via ndis2 driver 3.24 works up and down... though

the
> > speed at 100Mb never goes over 200MB/min. Considering these are 1.7GHz
> > Celerons, we should expect considerably higher. Even attempts to push a
> > single client can and does fail with no other devices on the network and

a
> > dedicated pipe from the server to that single client.
> >
> > Cabling has been ruled out as a possibility. This is happening at all

sites
> > these machines are going into, with many different network

configurations,
> > loads etc... Meanwhile all Intel based connections fly as usual.
> >
> > Does anyone have an ndis2 dos driver for this RealTek PHY that is

optimized
> > for Ghost and works at all connection speeds?

>
> The Celeron has to copy the data via block move from a receive buffer
> into a space the rest of the software stack can use it. It could then
> be copied via DMA. The RTL8129/39 are not high performance ethernet
> devices, so are probably incapable of keeping up with the data rate.
>
> http://www.scyld.com/pipermail/realt...st/001468.html
> http://www.corega.co.jp/product/os/source/rtl8139.c
>
> You didn't mention it, but you are probably multicasting. Maybe
> the source machine should have a lower performance than the destination
> machine(s), so there is less chance of dropping packets at the
> dest. Maybe there is a network throttling parameter in Windows
> for the source machine ?
>
> Just guesses,
> Paul



 
Reply With Quote
 
Ghislain
Guest
Posts: n/a
 
      3rd Nov 2003
Have you tried the -BUFFERSIZE=8 switch? I had that performance issue with a
different NIC and that switch resolved it.

"Robert Sudbury" <(E-Mail Removed)>
wrote in message news:rgfpb.3429$(E-Mail Removed)...
> At work we're rolling out our first non-Intel based onboard nic mobos in
> years, the Asus P4BGL-MX/533.
>
> The latest available ndis2 driver from RealTek for the RTL8139 in DOS

(3.24)
> has issues... or is it the chip... or the power supplies... or mobo

itself?
>
> We use Ghost7 Enterprise for pushing the desktop images. At first I

thought
> the issues may be related to the 3Com 1100/3300 switches in between the
> clients and the server but no.
>
> These machines fail the ghost PUSH process either immediately or whenever,
> when connected via 10Mb, full or half duplex... guaranteed. They will

also
> fail a manual ghost download via a DOS boot disk and the 3.24 ndis2

driver,
> but uploads are okay.
>
> When connected at 100Mb, it's a crap shoot whether PUSH will work, but
> manually connecting via ndis2 driver 3.24 works up and down... though the
> speed at 100Mb never goes over 200MB/min. Considering these are 1.7GHz
> Celerons, we should expect considerably higher. Even attempts to push a
> single client can and does fail with no other devices on the network and a
> dedicated pipe from the server to that single client.
>
> Cabling has been ruled out as a possibility. This is happening at all

sites
> these machines are going into, with many different network configurations,
> loads etc... Meanwhile all Intel based connections fly as usual.
>
> Does anyone have an ndis2 dos driver for this RealTek PHY that is

optimized
> for Ghost and works at all connection speeds?
>
> --
> ]Robert[ remove "ALLOF YOURCLOTHES" to reply
>
>



 
Reply With Quote
 
 
 
Reply

Thread Tools
Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are Off


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Ghost 8.0 worse than Ghost 7.5 (or Ghost 2003 vs Ghost 2002) J.W. Storage Devices 16 5th Jan 2005 11:31 PM
P4BGL-MX533 and P4 2,4 533 driekes Asus Motherboards 0 31st Mar 2004 03:52 PM
P4BGL-MX + USB2.0 + 98se DaveWe Asus Motherboards 1 28th Nov 2003 05:52 AM
ASUS P4BGL-MX Per Kristoffer Meyer Asus Motherboards 2 5th Nov 2003 11:23 PM
Re: P4BGL-MX Cpu Configuration Question Steve Hitchman Asus Motherboards 0 25th Jun 2003 03:09 PM


Features
 

Advertising
 

Newsgroups
 


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 10:48 AM.