Hello,
I am trying to get my 20MB Miniscribe 3.5" hard drive running again.
The problem is that it doesn't spin up anymore when I power it up. I
disassembled the drive's PCB, and swapped it with the PCB from a
working drive, and the other HD works with both PCBs, so proving the
problem is with the spindle motor itself.
Looking closer at it, I notice that when I power it up, the platter
spins about 1/4 of a revolution, then stops forever, until I power off
and on again. Rotating it manually doesn't fix it.

What could be the problem? I feel that if I can get the HDD to
correctly spin again, I should be able to access the data. This drive
is vintage, so I'm doing all efforts to rescue it.

Thanks for any information, any hint, or any similar situation
experienced.

Luc.

On 12/02/11 12:59 pm, XYLOPHONE wrote:

> I am trying to get my 20MB Miniscribe 3.5" hard drive running again.
> The problem is that it doesn't spin up anymore when I power it up. I
> disassembled the drive's PCB, and swapped it with the PCB from a
> working drive, and the other HD works with both PCBs, so proving the
> problem is with the spindle motor itself.
> Looking closer at it, I notice that when I power it up, the platter
> spins about 1/4 of a revolution, then stops forever, until I power off
> and on again. Rotating it manually doesn't fix it.
>
> What could be the problem? I feel that if I can get the HDD to
> correctly spin again, I should be able to access the data. This drive
> is vintage, so I'm doing all efforts to rescue it.

"Vintage"!? Wasn't it on one of those drives that Noah kept track of all
the animals? :-)

Have you tried giving the drive a sharp twist about the axis of the spindle?

Perce

On 3/12/2011 5:43 AM, Percival P. Cassidy wrote:
> On 12/02/11 12:59 pm, XYLOPHONE wrote:
>
>> I am trying to get my 20MB Miniscribe 3.5" hard drive running again.
>> The problem is that it doesn't spin up anymore when I power it up. I
>> disassembled the drive's PCB, and swapped it with the PCB from a
>> working drive, and the other HD works with both PCBs, so proving the
>> problem is with the spindle motor itself.
>> Looking closer at it, I notice that when I power it up, the platter
>> spins about 1/4 of a revolution, then stops forever, until I power off
>> and on again. Rotating it manually doesn't fix it.
>>
>> What could be the problem? I feel that if I can get the HDD to
>> correctly spin again, I should be able to access the data. This drive
>> is vintage, so I'm doing all efforts to rescue it.
>
> "Vintage"!? Wasn't it on one of those drives that Noah kept track of all
> the animals? :-)
>
> Have you tried giving the drive a sharp twist about the axis of the
> spindle?
>
> Perce

That should work! Sounds like the OP has what is termed a "stiction
fault". This is caused by the heads being stuck to the platter. The
sharp twist, often with power applied, is enough to break the "stiction"
and allow the heads to float free. Note that, if power is applied when
doing it, there is a risk of damage so treat the device with kids gloves
if you need to do it this way.

Haven't seen this fault in many a long year. No doubt this is due to off
platter head parking mechanisms on all drives nowadays.

--

Krypsis

In comp.sys.ibm.pc.hardware.storage XYLOPHONE <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote:
> Hello,
> I am trying to get my 20MB Miniscribe 3.5" hard drive running again.
> The problem is that it doesn't spin up anymore when I power it up. I
> disassembled the drive's PCB, and swapped it with the PCB from a
> working drive, and the other HD works with both PCBs, so proving the
> problem is with the spindle motor itself.
> Looking closer at it, I notice that when I power it up, the platter
> spins about 1/4 of a revolution, then stops forever, until I power off
> and on again. Rotating it manually doesn't fix it.

> What could be the problem? I feel that if I can get the HDD to
> correctly spin again, I should be able to access the data. This drive
> is vintage, so I'm doing all efforts to rescue it.

> Thanks for any information, any hint, or any similar situation
> experienced.

> Luc.

First, if the data has any real worth, STOP MESSING AROUND and
get help from a professional data recovery service. Chances are you
will just make matters worse.

As you say the drive spins 1/4 revolution, so it cannot be stiction.

Sounds like not all coils in the spindle motor get powered. As
you tried the PCB swap, this would not be a problem with the motor
driver amplifiers. One possibility is a contact problem.
Another one is a possibly broken winding in the motor itself.
Both can be debugged with a multi-tester by mesuring winding
resistances. (If you have no clue what I am talking about, then
you are not qualified to look into this, sorry.)

The contact problem is typically easy to fix temporarily
when located. The broken winding is usually unfixable.

Arno
--
Arno Wagner, Dr. sc. techn., Dipl. Inform., CISSP -- Email: (E-Mail Removed)
GnuPG: ID: 1E25338F FP: 0C30 5782 9D93 F785 E79C 0296 797F 6B50 1E25 338F
----
Cuddly UI's are the manifestation of wishful thinking. -- Dylan Evans

On 2 déc, 19:59, Arno <m...@privacy.net> wrote:
> In comp.sys.ibm.pc.hardware.storage XYLOPHONE <rhubar...@yahoo.com> wrote:
>
> > Hello,
> > I am trying to get my 20MB Miniscribe 3.5" hard drive running again.
> > The problem is that it doesn't spin up anymore when I power it up. I
> > disassembled the drive's PCB, and swapped it with the PCB from a
> > working drive, and the other HD works with both PCBs, so proving the
> > problem is with the spindle motor itself.
> > Looking closer at it, I notice that when I power it up, the platter
> > spins about 1/4 of a revolution, then stops forever, until I power off
> > and on again. Rotating it manually doesn't fix it.
> > What could be the problem? I feel that if I can get the HDD to
> > correctly spin again, I should be able to access the data. This drive
> > is vintage, so I'm doing all efforts to rescue it.
> > Thanks for any information, any hint, or any similar situation
> > experienced.
> > Luc.
>
> First, if the data has any real worth, STOP MESSING AROUND and
> get help from a professional data recovery service. Chances are you
> will just make matters worse.
>
> As you say the drive spins 1/4 revolution, so it cannot be stiction.
>
> Sounds like not all coils in the spindle motor get powered. As
> you tried the PCB swap, this would not be a problem with the motor
> driver amplifiers. One possibility is a contact problem.
> Another one is a possibly broken winding in the motor itself.
> Both can be debugged with a multi-tester by mesuring winding
> resistances. (If you have no clue what I am talking about, then
> you are not qualified to look into this, sorry.)
>
> The contact problem is typically easy to fix temporarily
> when located. The broken winding is usually unfixable.
>
> Arno
> --
> Arno Wagner, Dr. sc. techn., Dipl. Inform., CISSP -- Email: a...@wagner.name
> GnuPG: *ID: 1E25338F *FP: 0C30 5782 9D93 F785 E79C *0296 797F 6B50 1E25 338F
> ----
> Cuddly UI's are the manifestation of wishful thinking. -- Dylan Evans

Thanks Arno, I'll carefully try to see the contacts.

However, I forgot to mention that, when I first removed the PCB,
everything underneath was covered with tiny DARK BLACK dust, just like
black laser printer toner, or maybe even smaller grain powder. I
gently wiped all that black dust away. When I removed the PCB from the
working HDD, there was a little bit of that black dust, but far less
than on the non-spinning drive.

Does this dust make a click to anyone?

Thanks again...

In comp.sys.ibm.pc.hardware.storage XYLOPHONE <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote:
> On 2 déc, 19:59, Arno <m...@privacy.net> wrote:
>> In comp.sys.ibm.pc.hardware.storage XYLOPHONE <rhubar...@yahoo.com> wrote:
>>
>> > Hello,
>> > I am trying to get my 20MB Miniscribe 3.5" hard drive running again.
>> > The problem is that it doesn't spin up anymore when I power it up. I
>> > disassembled the drive's PCB, and swapped it with the PCB from a
>> > working drive, and the other HD works with both PCBs, so proving the
>> > problem is with the spindle motor itself.
>> > Looking closer at it, I notice that when I power it up, the platter
>> > spins about 1/4 of a revolution, then stops forever, until I power off
>> > and on again. Rotating it manually doesn't fix it.
>> > What could be the problem? I feel that if I can get the HDD to
>> > correctly spin again, I should be able to access the data. This drive
>> > is vintage, so I'm doing all efforts to rescue it.
>> > Thanks for any information, any hint, or any similar situation
>> > experienced.
>> > Luc.
>>
>> First, if the data has any real worth, STOP MESSING AROUND and
>> get help from a professional data recovery service. Chances are you
>> will just make matters worse.
>>
>> As you say the drive spins 1/4 revolution, so it cannot be stiction.
>>
>> Sounds like not all coils in the spindle motor get powered. As
>> you tried the PCB swap, this would not be a problem with the motor
>> driver amplifiers. One possibility is a contact problem.
>> Another one is a possibly broken winding in the motor itself.
>> Both can be debugged with a multi-tester by mesuring winding
>> resistances. (If you have no clue what I am talking about, then
>> you are not qualified to look into this, sorry.)
>>
>> The contact problem is typically easy to fix temporarily
>> when located. The broken winding is usually unfixable.
>>
>> Arno
>> --
>> Arno Wagner, Dr. sc. techn., Dipl. Inform., CISSP -- Email: a...@wagner.name
>> GnuPG: *ID: 1E25338F *FP: 0C30 5782 9D93 F785 E79C *0296 797F 6B50 1E25 338F
>> ----
>> Cuddly UI's are the manifestation of wishful thinking. -- Dylan Evans
>
> Thanks Arno, I'll carefully try to see the contacts.
>
> However, I forgot to mention that, when I first removed the PCB,
> everything underneath was covered with tiny DARK BLACK dust, just like
> black laser printer toner, or maybe even smaller grain powder. I
> gently wiped all that black dust away. When I removed the PCB from the
> working HDD, there was a little bit of that black dust, but far less
> than on the non-spinning drive.
>
> Does this dust make a click to anyone?
>
> Thanks again...

Disintegrated foam perhaps? I seem to remember dismantling a drive
with a thin piece of foam between the pc board and the drive. Might
have been to dampen vibration.

Jerry

On Fri, 2 Dec 2011 22:44:40 -0800 (PST), XYLOPHONE
<(E-Mail Removed)> put finger to keyboard and composed:

>However, I forgot to mention that, when I first removed the PCB,
>everything underneath was covered with tiny DARK BLACK dust, just like
>black laser printer toner, or maybe even smaller grain powder. I
>gently wiped all that black dust away. When I removed the PCB from the
>working HDD, there was a little bit of that black dust, but far less
>than on the non-spinning drive.

Is there a sintered carbon brush that bleeds the static electricity
off the motor shaft?

- Franc Zabkar
--
Please remove one 'i' from my address when replying by email.

Jerry Peters wrote
> XYLOPHONE <(E-Mail Removed)> wrote
>> Arno <m...@privacy.net> wrote
>>> XYLOPHONE <rhubar...@yahoo.com> wrote

>>>> I am trying to get my 20MB Miniscribe 3.5" hard drive running
>>>> again. The problem is that it doesn't spin up anymore when I power
>>>> it up. I disassembled the drive's PCB, and swapped it with the PCB
>>>> from a working drive, and the other HD works with both PCBs, so
>>>> proving the problem is with the spindle motor itself.
>>>> Looking closer at it, I notice that when I power it up, the platter
>>>> spins about 1/4 of a revolution, then stops forever, until I power
>>>> off and on again. Rotating it manually doesn't fix it.
>>>> What could be the problem? I feel that if I can get the HDD to
>>>> correctly spin again, I should be able to access the data. This
>>>> drive is vintage, so I'm doing all efforts to rescue it.
>>>> Thanks for any information, any hint, or any similar situation
>>>> experienced.

>>> First, if the data has any real worth, STOP MESSING AROUND and
>>> get help from a professional data recovery service. Chances are you
>>> will just make matters worse.

>>> As you say the drive spins 1/4 revolution, so it cannot be stiction.

>>> Sounds like not all coils in the spindle motor get powered. As
>>> you tried the PCB swap, this would not be a problem with the
>>> motor driver amplifiers. One possibility is a contact problem.
>>> Another one is a possibly broken winding in the motor itself.
>>> Both can be debugged with a multi-tester by mesuring winding
>>> resistances. (If you have no clue what I am talking about, then
>>> you are not qualified to look into this, sorry.)

>>> The contact problem is typically easy to fix temporarily
>>> when located. The broken winding is usually unfixable.

>> Thanks Arno, I'll carefully try to see the contacts.

>> However, I forgot to mention that, when I first removed the PCB,
>> everything underneath was covered with tiny DARK BLACK dust, just
>> like black laser printer toner, or maybe even smaller grain powder. I
>> gently wiped all that black dust away. When I removed the PCB from
>> the working HDD, there was a little bit of that black dust, but far
>> less than on the non-spinning drive.

>> Does this dust make a click to anyone?

>> Thanks again...

> Disintegrated foam perhaps?

I've never seen any foam deteriorate as comprehensively as that.

> I seem to remember dismantling a drive with a thin
> piece of foam between the pc board and the drive.

Yes, some Seagates did have that at one time.

> Might have been to dampen vibration.

Dont believe it was for that.

In article <(E-Mail Removed)>, (E-Mail Removed) wrote:
>On Fri, 2 Dec 2011 22:44:40 -0800 (PST), XYLOPHONE
><(E-Mail Removed)> put finger to keyboard and composed:
>
>>However, I forgot to mention that, when I first removed the PCB,
>>everything underneath was covered with tiny DARK BLACK dust, just like
>>black laser printer toner, or maybe even smaller grain powder. I
>>gently wiped all that black dust away. When I removed the PCB from the
>>working HDD, there was a little bit of that black dust, but far less
>>than on the non-spinning drive.
>
>Is there a sintered carbon brush that bleeds the static electricity
>off the motor shaft?
>
>- Franc Zabkar
I remember those from my Atari ST years. You occasionally would get them
making god awefull sounds when they would wear down and some would suggest
anything from sewing machine oil(3 in 1 oil), to using a dab of facial grease
(Shrugs head???) to stop the squealing.

XYLOPHONE wrote:

>
> I am trying to get my 20MB Miniscribe 3.5" hard drive running again.
> The problem is that it doesn't spin up anymore when I power it up. I
> disassembled the drive's PCB, and swapped it with the PCB from a
> working drive, and the other HD works with both PCBs, so proving the
> problem is with the spindle motor itself.
> Looking closer at it, I notice that when I power it up, the platter
> spins about 1/4 of a revolution, then stops forever, until I power off
> and on again. Rotating it manually doesn't fix it.
> What could be the problem? I feel that if I can get the HDD to
> correctly spin again, I should be able to access the data. This drive
> is vintage, so I'm doing all efforts to rescue it.

Does the RedHill.net.au have any info? HDDguru.com forums are
dominated by people who do HD repair and data recovery.

I would try unplugging the cables from that motor and the motor of a
working drive and compare the resistance readings of their coils.
However resistance measurements don't always tell everything about
coils, and for that you need to ring the coil:

http://members.ozemail.com.au/~bobpar/k7205.pdf

http://repairfaq.org/sam/flytest.htm

Is it possible to replace the motor without opening the drive? I have
a feeling dust would be a problem if even if the motor can be removed
that way.