PC Review


Reply
Thread Tools Rate Thread

AntiSpyware - Yahoo Anti-Spy, PestScan, Ad-aware, Spybot, and McAfee AntiSpyware

 
 
BillR
Guest
Posts: n/a
 
      3rd Oct 2004
Yahoo Anti-Spy (available via the Yahoo Toolbar) is PestPatrol-based.
Rather to my surprise, when I ran PestScan and Anti-Spy today, the results
were different.

I originally guessed Anti-Spy was based on Web Root Spy Sweeper because of
the close resemblance of the icons, however a PestPatrol press release
(repeat that quickly five times) says:
"The technology that Yahoo! is using is based on a Software Developers
Toolkit that PestPatrol has developed for such partnership opportunities.
Other companies that PestPatrol has partnered with include Zone Labs,
Authentium, Zero Knowledge Systems, Stomp, and PC Pitstop to name a few."
-- http://www.pestpatrol.com/News_Media...ws06040401.asp

I also offer yet another more-than-one-is-better anecdote. I've been
running without a software firewall or cookie blocker for several days (just
SpywareBlaster, teatimer, WinPatrol, antivirus, and NAT) so I've accumulated
a larger than normal collection of garbage. I decided to do a little
very(!) informal comparison.
* I ran Spybot S&D and removed almost everything it found.
* I then ran Yahoo Anti-Spy and Ad-aware Personal SE in parallel. Each
found several items that Spybot and the other missed. I removed or excluded
these items. (Ad-aware always identifies several useful favorites as
"potential hijackers" for reasons that are not always clear to me.)
* Next, I ran McAfee's new AntiSpyware ($). It found a couple of new items,
including the remnants of a trojan (maybe), all of which I removed.
* Finally, I ran PestScan. It reported a pair of related adware registry
entries the others missed and several additional suspect cookies. I was a
little surprised since I had recently run Yahoo Anti-Spy.
* Without making any of the PestScan changes, I ran Yahoo Anti-Spy again.
This time it found nothing at all.
This result is consistent with having removed everything Anti-Spy found
earlier; it is not consistent with Anti-Spy being based on the most current
PestPatrol db. The Yahoo Anti-Spy removal feature is handy and so far has
not damaged anything (AFAIK), but I'll still be running PestScan on
occasion. Oh well.

When installing Yahoo Toolbar, be sure to have a good registry monitor
running. The most recent Yahoo Toolbar tried to replace my default home
page as well as changing the IE search bar. I don't remember an earlier
version trying to do both.

Yahoo recently released v1.6 of Anti-Spy. I noticed that their reporting
system includes an entry for v1.7 so I presume it will arrive soon.

PestPatrol was acquired by Computer Associates. I hope that PestScan
continues to be supported. It is definitely on my "100 most useful sites"
list.

BillR




 
Reply With Quote
 
 
 
 
curt@redsox.com
Guest
Posts: n/a
 
      3rd Oct 2004
BillR wrote:
> Yahoo Anti-Spy (available via the Yahoo Toolbar) is PestPatrol-based.
> Rather to my surprise, when I ran PestScan and Anti-Spy today, the results
> were different.
>
> I originally guessed Anti-Spy was based on Web Root Spy Sweeper because of
> the close resemblance of the icons, however a PestPatrol press release
> (repeat that quickly five times) says:
> "The technology that Yahoo! is using is based on a Software Developers
> Toolkit that PestPatrol has developed for such partnership opportunities.
> Other companies that PestPatrol has partnered with include Zone Labs,
> Authentium, Zero Knowledge Systems, Stomp, and PC Pitstop to name a few."
> -- http://www.pestpatrol.com/News_Media...ws06040401.asp
>
> I also offer yet another more-than-one-is-better anecdote. I've been
> running without a software firewall or cookie blocker for several days (just
> SpywareBlaster, teatimer, WinPatrol, antivirus, and NAT) so I've accumulated
> a larger than normal collection of garbage. I decided to do a little
> very(!) informal comparison.
> * I ran Spybot S&D and removed almost everything it found.
> * I then ran Yahoo Anti-Spy and Ad-aware Personal SE in parallel. Each
> found several items that Spybot and the other missed. I removed or excluded
> these items. (Ad-aware always identifies several useful favorites as
> "potential hijackers" for reasons that are not always clear to me.)
> * Next, I ran McAfee's new AntiSpyware ($). It found a couple of new items,
> including the remnants of a trojan (maybe), all of which I removed.
> * Finally, I ran PestScan. It reported a pair of related adware registry
> entries the others missed and several additional suspect cookies. I was a
> little surprised since I had recently run Yahoo Anti-Spy.
> * Without making any of the PestScan changes, I ran Yahoo Anti-Spy again.
> This time it found nothing at all.
> This result is consistent with having removed everything Anti-Spy found
> earlier; it is not consistent with Anti-Spy being based on the most current
> PestPatrol db. The Yahoo Anti-Spy removal feature is handy and so far has
> not damaged anything (AFAIK), but I'll still be running PestScan on
> occasion. Oh well.
>
> When installing Yahoo Toolbar, be sure to have a good registry monitor
> running. The most recent Yahoo Toolbar tried to replace my default home
> page as well as changing the IE search bar. I don't remember an earlier
> version trying to do both.
>
> Yahoo recently released v1.6 of Anti-Spy. I noticed that their reporting
> system includes an entry for v1.7 so I presume it will arrive soon.
>
> PestPatrol was acquired by Computer Associates. I hope that PestScan
> continues to be supported. It is definitely on my "100 most useful sites"
> list.


I just wrote a new anti-spyware page last night:
http://www.somebodyhelpme.info/spyware/spyware.html

These are all free tools which I use for battling tough malware. The
first two apps I always use are Spybot and Ad Aware. Those are usually
enough to eliminate the problem. In really tough cases, you need to dig
deeper and the other apps help for that. I also install SpywareBlaster
on all machines but, to be honest, I haven't found it that helpful for
prevention. I don't install SpywareGuard or Startup Monitor on all
machines because they're too confusing for your average end user.

If I missed any that people consider essential (freeware only), please
email me:
(E-Mail Removed)
 
Reply With Quote
 
michael andrews
Guest
Posts: n/a
 
      3rd Oct 2004

<(E-Mail Removed)> wrote in message news:%LH7d.2815$gk.1714@okepread01...

> I just wrote a new anti-spyware page last night:
> http://www.somebodyhelpme.info/spyware/spyware.html


Please add links to forums to Hijackthis logs

And a link to this site please.
http://www.spywarewarrior.com/rogue_anti-spyware.htm

And links to spyware and anti virus groups.

alt.comp.anti-virus
alt.privacy.spyware

ty


 
Reply With Quote
 
 
 
Reply

Thread Tools
Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are Off


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Antispyware - Spycatcher, a reputable complement to Spybot , adaware and Microsoft Antispyware Aaron Freeware 1 26th Dec 2005 01:06 PM
Ms Antispyware and Ad-Aware =?Utf-8?B?UmVuYXRvLUl0YWx5?= Spyware Announcements 4 15th Dec 2005 01:32 PM
MS AntiSpyware vs Ad-Aware Keith Spyware Discussion 6 19th Jan 2005 04:21 PM
Yahoo! Anti-Spy versus Microsoft AntiSpyware Michael Jones Spyware Discussion 3 7th Jan 2005 09:21 AM
McAfee 2005 All In One, McAfee AntiSpyware V1.0 2005, McAfee Personal Firewall Plus V6.0 2005, McAfee QuickClean V5.0 2005, McAfee SpamKiller V6.0 2005, McAfee VirusScan V9.0 2005, new !, other code_fu Anti-Virus 0 1st Oct 2004 11:00 PM


Features
 

Advertising
 

Newsgroups
 


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:13 PM.